free viagra or cialisany danger in taking adderall and cialiszithromax buy canadalevitra expensiveviagra and alcholdoes aspirin can be used as viagrazydus cadila viagracialis and alcoholultimate diet pillslegal issues with diet pillsi took two cialis pillswhy viagrara cost so muchorlistat eczane onlineviagra ajantabuy lipitor pfizerviagra for women or something betterejaculation while taking cialisviagra stores in birmighamcialis bad side effectslipitor otc wall street journalamoxicillin 500 how many dayshow long viagra states in the systemcost of monitored clomid cyclecialis 3how to original viagraviagra quadriplegicshow to use to viagraallie diet pillsclomid nolvadex dosetadalafil espanolis vega 100 and cialis10mg of cialis dailylowest cost of viagra per pillwhat is sildenafil made fromwhat would 1 cialis do to youwhat does viagra do if a woman takes itcan women take tadalafilhow much viagra does it take to stay hardplavix special authorization alberta blue crosscan you take enzyte with cialishoodia cactus hoodia cactus diet pillgeneric lipitor. leg painlexapro generic differenceviagra and adipexhow much viagra can u takecena cialis w angliiwill amoxil 500 mg work for yeast infectioncialis vs viagra wars which one is the bestshe took unprescribed clomid it workedripoff viagramissed lexapro dose side effectto buy cialis in dubaicialis super active vs soft tabhow long will you have an erection with viagrathe difference between dayside and lasixzovirax 200 mg pillis daily cialis bettersigns propecia is workingbuy generic propecia cheapcialis indian nameviagra buy now pay later ukclopidogrel generic fda warningviagra age limitationwomen gum cialishow fast can you lose weight on topamaxcialis 5mg prijsviagra increase libidocanada pharmacy tadalafil ciplabuy brand name cialis online paypalviagra kosten deutschlandwhere to buy cialis from beijingthe effect 10mg of levitra in womenviagra dlugosc dzialaniatadalafil api manufacturers indialevitra dosage directionsviagramailing listbuy clomid 50mgcan viagra show herpeslevaquin side effects how longviagra 100 mg accepts paypal uscialis copla india pricesprednisone 10mg dose pack how to takecialis and vitaminscialis and multivitaminspruche zu viagrahow to buy viagra in kuala lumpurreal safe generic cialiscanadian supplier of viagraneurontin generic gabapentinmiltary and viagraeffect of cialis on teenage boysgeneric brands of cialis onlinecan you get hard quickly after cumming using viagraviagrasrbijais alcohol bad with viagrazyprexa cost without insurance at cvsnexium average dose100 mg cialiswhat can you buy over the counter that is like viagracialis on nhshow does it take for cialiswhat is better out generic viagra or cialisviagra suppliesviagra 100 milligramcan you buy pink viagrabreast diet feeding pill whilelevitra 3 pillwhat can happen if you take more than one cialisin what form does iv acyclovir comesrxcanada viagradoes walmart in hazard ky sale zithromaxzyprexa cost irelandmy wife likes cialisprednisone pack 6 daywhat if u snort a viagra 100mgteens using cialis pillscan viagra cause problems with ejaculationclomid for men costscialis sotololviagra100mg .comcialis exceeding expiration datedoes cialis intensifycan i take cialis if i ma taking diovanpill cheap viagracostco sells cialisbuy cialis canada drugsviagra inunited statesmichael baxter canada viagra bangkoksteroid hair loss cialisbuy alli orlistat online australiacialis prohormonessildenafil dosage 300flagyl 400g what are the forlevitra difference between viagraviagra cialis levitra canadaebay uk viagracost of metronidazole at walmart in lima ohwoman on cialis commercialcialis headache afterhoodia gordonii pure hoodia gordonii hoodia diet pillgas station same ingredient as viagrabuy paxil nowis there a working womens viagrareview viagra gel sachetscaverject versus viagraazithromycin 1g single dose priceclonazepam and viagrabuy viagra 100 ukviagra for cheap with no prescriptionshow long does cialis remain in your systemplant viagra is there any precautionsviagra online shippingwhat do the cialis commercials with the headphones meancompare cialis and flomaxwhere can i buy ciproxin in prestonhow to make sildenafil citrate at hometadalafil 20mg canadian pharmacybuy fluconazole in liquidpowered by 4images viagrafluconazole cost in indiahow long does the viagra takjes to workcialis 20 mg cenapatient reviews for cialiswhat is zithromax nedircan you cum using cialisviagra how longcanadian drug cialiswoman in cialis commercialsviagra alternative indiawhere to buy cialis in cincinnati ohclopidogrel how suppliedcan a normal boy use viagradiet pills disadvantagesbest time to take red viagratell if lasix workingis taking 2 cialis pillsbuy cialis in stores torontowill the minute clinic write a prescription for viagraviagra 100mg price australian pharmacyviagra comprohow much does viagra decrease blood pressureparoxetine drug informationlifta vs levitralipitor commercial icewho need viagrapaxil 10mg genericgeneric brand of maxaltblue cross blue shield cover viagra massachusettsxenical weight loss pills onlineviagra 100mg discountprofessional cialis onlineageninnargininecialishow much time before propecia workwhen levitra failsprednisone side effects medsafecialis 20 mg chinapremarin cream how long does it take to workhow to get real viagrasomething is better than viagra in chinaviagra irritable side effectscialis e os efeitos colateraishow long did fluconazole take to treat itchy breatszithromax how long till it works on urethritiscialis 40 mgszestril safetyeffects of viagra on bone marrowcialis. walmartguess what the main ingredient in viagra iswhere to find viagra in ottaware buy viagraresearch drugs nolvadexcost of 2 grams of azithromycinwhere can i buy super kamagraviagra how many minutes5mlg cialis daily tabletsprescription for desi viagratoronto walkin clinic prescription for viagrawhat happens if you give levitra to a womandiet pills and fat burnerscheap pharmacy online sell xenicaldoxycycline not workingjacksonville florida diet pillis it safe to order cialis onlineis propecia prescription expensivewhen viagra stoping workingpurchase of cialis in floridahow is bactrim absorbedwere can you buy viagra in taronto camost effective way use viagraprescription lamisil with appusisviagra for kardashiansviagra in sportsshould i discontinue cialis before surgeryquetiapine obsessive compulsive disorderdisulfiram like reaction causing drugspulmonary lymphoma vardenafilcan we buy viagra in amstredambuy finasteride in ukwith viagra can i keep my erection after ejaculatingtaking cialis while on chemotherapyfind viagra free sitestadalafil 30mg bottlecialis 5mg online beogradfemales use cialiswhy is propecia no longer working25mg viagra young guysviagra cochabambahealthy men viagracounter diet over pill xenical20 mg escitalopram cost on the streethow long before take cialisdoes boots sell generic viagraviagra uk how muchviagra ehowcan you take ibuprofen before taking viagranizoral cialishow long will levitra work in the bodyorder celebrex from canadareviews viagra super activewhy cant he have an orgasm when he is taking viagracan one dose of cialis give multiple erectionslipitor 30 dayspurchase propecia in brazilsildenafil lasttadalafil canada customsfda finds natural diet pillshow long can i take finasterideadvice on buying generic viagracialis lily couponsdoes cialis work even if you do not have edlilly icos llc cialis professionalwhat happens if i take 100mg of viagrahow is buspar classifiedalbuterol neb solution online no prescriptionhow long does single dose of fluconazole stay in systemtype drug atomoxetineproscar dose for hair losscan a 21 year old take 100 mg viagraarticles about diet pills arsonmaximum dose of amoxicillin for surfer infectionbuy liquid albuterol perth western australiaacura viagracialis intakedoes daily use of cialis workhow long will anxiety last from gabapentin withdrawalviagra 50mg medicationesiste cialis de 40mgplavix generic walmartsoft gelatin sildenafilwhat happens if u take levitra and cialis togetherwhats the difference between viagra and cialistadalafil workis cvs selling the generic for singulair yetdo you need a prescription for amoxicillinlilly patent on cialishow to convince your girlfriend to take viagraviagra norvasclevitra use dailycialis canada commercialhow long does flutters last on lexaprowho can prescribe viagra in indiais viagra generic approved by fdabuy real pfizer viagra cheapalli diet pill for salebuy finasteride gel for baldnessbestway to take cialisdo all men take viagravijagracijalislevitra srbijaviagra professional pagando con carta paypaldoes levitra make u last longerwhat happens to long time propecia users who stoptamoxifen side effects drugindian herbal viagra retail in malaysiaflomax available genericwalgreen price for viagradoes viagra keep u hard after comingcialis anionwhatisbetterthanviagrasildenafil cloridratobuy azithromycin 1000 mg no prescriptionbest site to order nolvadex pctwhat is propecia and what does it donexium mups dosecialis fatiguelevitra u.s. pharmaciespaxil drug makerwhat is the price of viagra in malaysiacan levitra and viagra mixhow to buy viagra in bangalorecipro lingua ufficiale24 hr viagra noware there pills like viagra over the counterviagra should ifast delivery no prescription cialiswhat is the price of cialiswhat color is generic singulairgeneric levitra oral jelly indialevitra canada orderfrom where i can buy viagra in vancouvercan a man wtadalafilmasterbate then take viagradapoxetine and sildenafil tablets in indiagenric viagra vs real viagraviagra rate in dubaiwhere do you buy viagra in kuala lumpurdifference between tadalafil and sildenafildoes pfizer make viagra 120mg 150mgprices of levitra in uaegeneric cialis from philipinesgeneric cialis uk buying reviewhow much is 15g acyclovirbest time take cialisclomid pills purchase online reviewtopamax bipolar disorder reviewsdoest cialis helps last more withoit coming fasthow long does levitra erection lastbuy amoxicillin 100mgcan viagra be taken analeyhow long do you take diflucan for candidaoverdose lexaprogabapentin for facial painweekend.ee klub apolo .viagrapatient assistance for cialisgeneric viagra australia reviewcialis causes muscle paincan levitra be buy over counterwhy does viagra make you flushdoes sperm work on cialiscost of 30 day 5mg cialiscialis tadalafil walmart pricecan i take viagra and coumadinviagra 200mg for cheapviagra 60 centstake multiple daily cialis instead of single use pillcheap effective alternative viagrablue pill orlistat 60 mgsildenafil citrate 100mg tabletsviagra or cialis in bangkokwhere i can buy nexium in torontoketoconazole overdoseviagra e diabetesinformazioni su cialis genericolamisil pills and creamswhat happens if you stop taking propeciabuy ciprofloxacin overnightviagra usa on linewhat is singulair 10mg tablets for bronchitiswhen is the right age to take viagra 100 tabletcialis 40 mg dosage canadacan you cut a 5mg cialis in halfdoes viagra lose its effectivenesskamagra oral jelly 100mg suppliers next daydoes metronidazole cream work as well as tabletshow many mg of doxycycline hyclate for bronchitishow many times can you cum when using viagrais cialis can be used for premature ejuclationpropecia rogaine combo worksfluconazole single dose sizesildenafil five starssildenafil citrate tablets 100mg useslovenia viagracialis icoshow do you know if your viagra is real10mg vs. 20mg cialismedical reimbursement and viagradoes viagra work after you ejaculate in morningdoes propecia work for temple hair lossle cialis ne marche pasviagra prescripton st maartenbuy lasix forumwhat is the average cost for cialis for daily useviagra.what classwhich viagra is best i am 34 yearover the counter viagra scotlandviagra do not lose erection after ejaculationliquid cialis reciepezithromax drug classificationmexico viagra generictadalafil an wbcis viagra safe for women to takeviagra azwhat happen if women took viagracan a woman know that her man is on viagracheapest viagra online without prescriptiontaking viagra and antibioticstadalafil uv spectrais it possible to cut cialishow do i know if my shedding is from propeciaor notordering albuterol solutionwere to buy viagra pillscialis available in walgreens over counterhow many daily cialis can a person takewhat forms does metronidazole in autrali com ithe dangers of diet pillscan you get viagra from bootswhere can i buy viagra in torbaycan or will customs stop viagracialis and asprindo pharmacies in abu dhabi sell viagrataking viagra without ed cialiswhat a viagra does to a girltake viagra while drunkdo cialis generic workdoes cialis lose its effects over timebought cialis for grandfatherfluconazole max dose200 dose albuterol 17g mdi pricescan lisinopril 10 mg. dose cause kidney painthe dangers of cialisviagra pharmacy cyprushat is the difference between viagra and cobrablue c200 cialisreliable generic viagra ciplacialis nd levitra togetherzithromax oral suspension without prescriptionwhat happens when women have viagracosto ciproxina 500 mg nuevos solescvs generic viagra pricelevitra and womenviagra 2 days after cialisis levitra expensvepropecia costs at walmartprice for 6 viagras wallgreensvardenafil loverviagra for men price pakistanenhances cialiscialis black caratteristicheterazosin plus viagra30 day supply generic singulairhow long time viagra workis cialis 20 mg strength enoughmix viagra withorginal viagra hungariacelebrex online purchaseem i still hard after i cum on viagracialis made in francehow long does levitra stay in the bodyzithromax cost walgreensinteraction between levitra and niacinvardenafil belgiqueviagra danger of priapismwhy is sildenafil not available in pakistancheap viagra pills in tucson az.how much does insurance pay for cialissample pack of viagra200mg mygra sildenafilcanadian viagra two day deliveryviagra canada cheapinteraction viagra methadonetesco viagra st helens storeviagra customer reviewsviagra interaction sleeping tabletsviagra pinupfreeviagra fontbest generic viagra deals indiasuper strong mn ad womens viagrawhere to buy viagra pills in woodlands singaporehow to get propecia in malaysiahow long does it take for propecia workadvise on viagra

Jump to content


Photo

Interesting Conversation


  • Please log in to reply
74 replies to this topic

#41 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:12 AM

According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Cop out.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Not a cop out to them. If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating. I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The rosh is only concerned with learning torah working is not a reason not to fast.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#42 Psychodad

Psychodad

    88

  • Members
  • 7,376 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:14 AM

.

#43 Tova

Tova

    Godol Hador

  • Members
  • 3,230 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:15 AM

According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Cop out.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Not a cop out to them. If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating. I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The rosh is only concerned with learning torah working is not a reason not to fast.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

What's the rosh's opinion of women fasting?
If they're getting off for the second seder, then why can't they fast? (It's like a half-day-- yeshiva kids who go to school and presumably learn and are over bar/bat mitzvah fast, correct?)
Do they have a big breakfast? Or something small, simply to sustain themselves?
So little room, so much to say!
The day will come when I will be able to properly and fully express myself in my sig. Today is a sad day.

#44 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:18 AM

The rosh is only concerned with learning torah working is not a reason not to fast.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Who hires these people?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Good question

According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Cop out.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Not a cop out to them. If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating. I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The rosh is only concerned with learning torah working is not a reason not to fast.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

What's the rosh's opinion of women fasting?
If they're getting off for the second seder, then why can't they fast? (It's like a half-day-- yeshiva kids who go to school and presumably learn and are over bar/bat mitzvah fast, correct?)
Do they have a big breakfast? Or something small, simply to sustain themselves?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

This particular yeshiva does not give off second seder. Thats the point-the yeshiva wants them learning every seder. In normal yeshivos where guys fast they get off for second seder.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#45 accolade

accolade

    probably doesn't care

  • Members
  • 10,776 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:18 AM

Not a cop out to them.  If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating.  I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Why?
דעלך סני לחברך לא תעביד

#46 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:20 AM

Not a cop out to them.  If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating.  I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Why?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I just understand that a guy would not be able to learn well without eating. they need strength. I agree they need to eat to learn a whole day. I don't agree that they don't have to fast so that they could learn.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#47 accolade

accolade

    probably doesn't care

  • Members
  • 10,776 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:24 AM

I just understand that a guy would not be able to learn well without eating.  they need strength.  I agree they need to eat to learn a whole day.  I don't agree that they don't have to fast so that they could learn.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think they're deluding themselves and that, in most cases, they'd find wellsprings of strength they didn't know they had until they tried fasting and learning. I feel similarly about women/girls who claim to be too weak to fast with no basis.
דעלך סני לחברך לא תעביד

#48 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:26 AM

I just understand that a guy would not be able to learn well without eating.  they need strength.  I agree they need to eat to learn a whole day.  I don't agree that they don't have to fast so that they could learn.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think they're deluding themselves and that, in most cases, they'd find wellsprings of strength they didn't know they had until they tried fasting and learning. I feel similarly about women/girls who claim to be too weak to fast with no basis.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You are wrong- a guy can't fast a whole day and learn a whole day.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#49 accolade

accolade

    probably doesn't care

  • Members
  • 10,776 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:27 AM

You are wrong- a guy can't fast a whole day and learn a whole day.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Okay.
דעלך סני לחברך לא תעביד

#50 rashi613

rashi613

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 778 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:01 PM

His rosh yeshiva and the Brisker rav in eretz yisroel hold yeshiva guys don't fast because talmid torah is deoraysa and fasting is deranbanan.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I really don't see why they have to be mutually exclusive. :unsure:

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Additionally, there's not neccessarily a problem with an Issur D'rabbanan pushing off a mitvas aseh min haTorah. Think, for example, why don't we blow shofar when Rosh hashana falls out on Shabbos? Shofar is an aseh min hatorah and carrying is an issur d'rabbanan!!

#51 Daniel

Daniel

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 785 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:09 PM

You are wrong- a guy can't fast a whole day and learn a whole day.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Sure you can. On YK you spend a 25 hours fasting and davening. You tell me that fasting 25 hours and also having kavanah in your tefilos all day is possible, but fasting 12 hours and just learning isn't? :D

Sorry, these Brisker guys are real weaklings, if you ask me.

#52 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:10 PM

You are wrong- a guy can't fast a whole day and learn a whole day.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Sure you can. On YK you spend a 25 hours fasting and davening. You tell me that fasting 25 hours and also having kavanah in your tefilos all day is possible, but fasting 12 hours and just learning isn't? :D

Sorry, these Brisker guys are real weaklings, if you ask me.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Since I'm not a guy I can't swear by it but learning gemara takes the most energy more than davening. You don't have to think too much too daven as you do to learn.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#53 enigma

enigma

    רבנית

  • Members
  • 3,070 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:30 PM

I think they're deluding themselves and that, in most cases, they'd find wellsprings of strength they didn't know they had until they tried fasting and learning. I feel similarly about women/girls who claim to be too weak to fast with no basis.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

This bothers me as well. Before I started working, I never knew how many women don't fast, but now I'm sitting here hungry and half the office is munching. <_< :(
אין הדבר תלוי אלא בי

"Have you seen H&M this season? It looks like the 70's threw up on the 80's." ~holy

#54 Moshi

Moshi

    Little Reb Sunshine

  • Members
  • 21,046 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:36 PM

That is f-d up. They can't learn well without eating, but I'm supposed to sit here thirsty, hungry, with a splitting headache and write computer code?

Forget it, I'm going downstairs to get lunch.

:angry:
The L-rd may not come when you call, but He's always on time. -Lemon Andersen

Kabel et ha-emet mi-mi she-omro.

"All is by the hand of Heaven, except colds and fevers" -Ketubot 30a.

~My Blog~

#55 myaccountname

myaccountname

    Rebbe

  • Members
  • 1,209 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:38 PM

This newly married Brisker guy comes home one fast day after shachris and asks his wife for breakfast, she looks at him :wacko: arent you fasting today? No, he answers, I need to learn all day and can't do it when I'm fasting. So being a good wife she makes him a nice breakfast and sits down to eat with him. What are you doing, he asked? Eating with you she answered. No, you can't do that, we're not machmir on the women!
Thats why there is caramel and vanilla...

#56 Daniel

Daniel

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 785 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:44 PM

This newly married Brisker guy comes home one fast day after shachris and asks his wife for breakfast, she looks at him  :wacko: arent you fasting today? No, he answers, I need to learn all day and can't do it when I'm fasting. So being a good wife she makes him a nice breakfast and sits down to eat with him. What are you doing, he asked? Eating with you she answered. No, you can't do that, we're not machmir on the women!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


:D :D :D

#57 prototype

prototype

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 261 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:59 PM


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

what about a non-pregnant non-nursing mother with small children to care for?

#58 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 01:03 PM


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

what about a non-pregnant non-nursing mother with small children to care for?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

No heter for that.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#59 Guest_melech_*

Guest_melech_*
  • Guests

Posted 10 January 2006 - 01:04 PM

.

#60 myaccountname

myaccountname

    Rebbe

  • Members
  • 1,209 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 01:09 PM


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

what about a non-pregnant non-nursing mother with small children to care for?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

No heter for that.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Depends whom you ask. Ask Mindy.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


agree with melech

the Bobover Ruv ZT"L was very maikel with regards to fasting even for bucherim even on tisha b'av
Thats why there is caramel and vanilla...




1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users