awu moch cost cialsand viagra.lexapro not working second time now whatviagraodviagra pills without a presciptionwill cialis work with horny goat weedside effects of daily use cialiscymbalta at costcohow long does it take for diflucan to work for rashblob diet pill to buyciprofloxacin dose sbp prophylaxiscan i buy levitra over counterbest price for cialis brand 20 mg5th day zoloftwhen i take viagrawhat should lisinopril 10 mg with re 22 on it look likeviagra sale in dublinclomiphene how to getbuspar overdose dosagewhat is the street name for escitalopramreplace his cialis with placeboshow do orlistat tablets workmaca con cialis 5 mgpoor shelf life of cialisover the counter viagra in caymanviagra with wharfrin strokealternative to viagra naturalsingulair drug interactions zyrteclevitra juist gebruikenpurchase azithromycin with a mastercardrealistic prices for generic viagraviagra on pbs in australiaviagra del calabreseviagra alternatives that work in melbournebst price for cialis in canadaviagra 100 mg italiacipro xr purchase without prescriptionhow does zithromax workwhat pregnancy symptoms are experienced after clomidprednisone 10 mg tapering doses schedulebuy clomid in nova scotiagreenviagrachinahow can i use clomidcan i buy viagra online yahoo answershow much are 50 mg viagra at walmartcialis dosage bodybuildingclomid 50mg price online in pakistankamagra pill cutterhow long due the effect of viagra lastlisinopril cost germanyviagra expiry datewhat milligram of cialis should you take a daycanine ciprofloxacin overdosewill blue cross pay for cialistamoxifen uk buyget the best out of cialisdiscount pfizer viagra in the united statescan normal men use levitracialis and red rashviagra 15 year old150ml viagra discountwhat are seroquel side effectsdo i have to take propecia every dayviagra 100 in australiawill taking cialis and a vicodin help last longergeneric lexapro rashsingulair entra seguridad socialwhy does medicare not cover viagra 2013levitra tiranais cialis or viagra availoable on pbs in australiafda approval of generic cialissildenafil citrate tablets 100mg how to usesildenafil citrate 100mg tablevitra oral dispersibleviagra worlwideapodex tadalafillevitra safe for womenvarious diet pillhow do i get xenical in nigeriaviagra for dighow long viagra influence lastwhere can i buy viagra onlineside effects levitrahow long will may erection last with viagrawhy cant u take viagra and aspirineis levitra and viagra the samecialis crushedheapest vardenafil 20 mgs.viagra cost per pill walgrenstadalafil circular tabletscialis where to buy does shoppers drug mart carry itwhat is the strategic plan of action of montelukasttadalafil histologicalwhat is like viagra that is over the counterpurchase proventil hfafinland tamoxifen onlinecialis cost without insurance yahoonombre comercial de vardenafileffects of viagra on a normal maleviagra in qatar is availableviagra for petsworst headache from vardenafil or viagracan cialis make you hornyhow much does xenical cost 2012 australiaimpotence from propecia and cialisjapancialiswalmart viagra like productsoral amoxicillin for sale petviagra legel in ukwhy isnt viagra covered by health insurancecialis and lasting longerviagra and golfbuying surplus cialiswaktu reaksi cialis 20mghow long until fluconazole works for ringwormgeneric over the counter clomid at walmartis viagra harmful to menwhy not take two levitrasviagra b board frequency modificationcialis 20 mg levitrahoodia weight loss hoodia plant hoodia brand diet pillmetronidazole pills tasteconsecuencias del viagrahow long before viagra is out of your systemviagra in tamil language informationday6 10mg lexapro with anxietyviagra from the chemistoptimal dosage viagrawho manufactures cialisgeneric propecia cvslevitra esiste in thaicialis online sydneyforum about cialisis anxiety a side effect of cialisgeneric cialis bestellenre viagra products liability litigationsiperdoretviagralasix diuretic drughow long does viagra stay active in ur bodywhere does generic finasteride come fromhow long does diflucan 1 takeis viagra available over the counterviagra reviews indianslevitra and ejaculation problemviagra companybactrim suspension for sale uktadalafil sanafiviagra mumbai pharmacyhot long is cialis lasterection on cialisbuy viagra in montreal by pfizerphenergan breastfeeding safecan i buy cipro hc from uscialis bez recepty w apteceunited healthcare florida cover viagraviagra for retrograde ejaculationviagra mc mimo na jemlow dose buspar anxietyviagra sensibilidadindian viagra availabledoes the va provide cialis to veteransbuying cialis in dubaiviagra online by paypalviagra in china legal1 dose zithromaxwhat happens cialis no edsave websites for viagrametronidazole twice a dayis green viagra the same as bluepropecia generic pakistansmoking weed and having cialismixing viagra and marijuanaviagra like products germanycvspriceforcialiscan you order clomid onlinefemale viagra south africaviagra time between ejaculationsmoney order sildenafilamy ried is viagra really neededcialis and bathtubs whywellbutrin what is it fordiet pill clenbuteroldrug information wellbutrinviagra leicesterwas ist cialis 29what is difference between cialis 20 mg and 10mgviagra duration of actioncost of metformin 500 mg at walmartpropecia cost nexttaglasix horse costgeneric name of levaquinbeing to young to take cialismeth and viagra what do i doviagra biologischbest diet pills at gncpropecia diet pillbuspirone hydrochloride generic namewhere can i buy viagra in walthamstowwhat is homemade erectile dysfunctionviagra singapore over countercan one buy viagra over the counter in londonfree cialis vouchergeneric cialis versus real cialisgeneric viagra vs real viagrapowered by smf 2.0 lipitor generic brandswhats viagra and how does it costdiflucan 150 mg take how long to effectivecan i take cialis and clonidineviagra sale tescodoes viagra cause salty spermcialis in kansasstop indigestion from cialisdo circumcised men need viagrahow long should i take terbinafinecountries that sell viagra over the countercan sildenafil tablets be chewedmarijuana effect on viagracialis azonline prescription propeciawhat happenes if i take half a levitra 20mgxenical tablets for saleboots cialis pricescheapest tadalafil 20mg genericactor mccain in viagra commerialmercury drug doxycycline for chlamadia 100 mg pricebuying viagra in edmonton canadaviagra medicament kaufenviagra price in manilacost of nolvadex in indiawhy healthcare does not cover levitracheapest cialis online uk paypallexapro withdrawal drugs.comkamagra to buy hktadalafilcitratewikipediaviagra and things on the pbswhen propecia stops working does regaine helpbuy cialis online mexicopackaging of cialisxenical online australiacan i take cialis if im taking crestorcan i drink my viagra twicegeneric kamagra buycymbalta average dosebuy generic xenical sale philippineswhere can i purchase prednisonepills better than viagrais lipitor safeviagra female pinkgeneric plavix lawsuitviagra cost in englandonline tablets viagra chennaiviagra and spray in dubaiamoxil dose strep throatside effects of cytotec pillssildenafil discounts4dollar viagrahow many times can yo cum on viagrais viagra work for girl to need fuckhow to remove finasteride from body systemlexapro 20 mg for salecialis tablete kupovina onlinewhat is the maximum dosage of cialiswhat can i do to replace cialisare there different doses of levitrabupropion hcl costcan you buy viagra from shoppers drug martviagra cialis canadawhat does 80 milligram dose of diuretic lasixis generic valtrex safeuti cipro 3 daysman tiger herbal viagrawhat is the cheapest dose of sildenafillisinopril to buyif i start taking viagra is it for my entire lifemale thrush treatment fungus diflucan dosedoes soda prevent levitra from workingcan i take adderall after taking cialisbupropion what does it work onviagra max impactalbuterol sulfate safe pregnant womenstop stop viagracialis 5 mg of 20 mgbuy vaginal viagra suppositoriesfucked wife hard with viagraorder cialis and pay through paypalbuy generic viagra from staten island storehow much does a 90 day supply of clopidogrel costcialis philippinen kaufendo 6yr old cialis workis it illegal to order cialis onlinefree viagra next day deliverywhen was metronidazole discovered as a drugcialis side effects tinnitus25 mg cialisbuying albuterol from mexico onlinedoes viagra help with recovery timedoes kamagra workcomparison side effects sildenafil cialiscialis buy in bangkok cheapertesimonials men taking 40 mg of cialishow long does it take to kill ringworm with diflucanbetter erections viagra of cialisprescription price of cialis at walmarthow effective is xenical for weight losscialis free 20 mgmetronidazole and nitroglycerin drug interaction500 mg viagrawellbutrin generic cost walgreenspharmacy silagra brand name viagra cumwithuscom500g viagrametronidazole dose for diverticulitislargest doesage of cialiseviagra celias package dealswhat is the difference between amoxicillin and a z packviagra 100 splitviagra getestetviagra fur den pcmetformin extended release maximum doseviagra tramadolwhat strength of cialis should i takeviagra.com cape townlevaquin new zealand buyhow much does clomid cost in malaysialegal to buy cialis onlinedoes generic of singulair work the samehow long does a viagra eremarketing plan cialisalbuterol where to buyviagra dosage bodyweightprescription order propeciacialiscost in australiakamagra mieux viagrausing marijuana and levitraviagra motorcycle commercialdose metronidazole 25 dental geldoes sildenafil contain beta blockerseveryday levitra its oklasix online prescriptionlevitra 10 mg n1cialis reviews when to takegdje viagra kupitipackage insert for cialiscom alli alli diet pillviagra lietuvojwhat is the best natural alternative to viagragralic and viagracheap sildenafil for womenviagra home office torontocialis et prostatecan i take diazepam with viagraconstituent of viagrageneric cialis 10 mg.strattera buy from canadacialis in jakarta indonesiado poeple taking cialis have issues reaching orgasmchick fucked on viagrawho is the woman cialis commercialwhat is doxycycline potencytaking cialis for p.e.viagra 500 mg price in indiageneric cialis 10 milligramshow much is strattera 40 mg worthwalmart pharmacy levitra pricehow to get clomiphene citrate in south africaviagra dose for juniorswhat to expect when you take viagraviagra ottawaviagra professional tablets in urdu benefitsprescription topamaxhow much is albuterol vial without insuranceis it dangerous to buy viagra onlinewhat is ciprogeneric cialis fedexinsert sildenafil citrate in bangladesh squareamoxil online pharmacycompanies make generic wellbutrinwhat dose of prednisone for poison ivy for 8 year oldque es levitrageneric plavix nameviagra generic manufacturer locationequivalent dose paxil zoloftbactrim rash after 10 daysgeneric vardenafil 40mg usaorder propecia canadacialis crushtell if lexapro workinghealthy man viagrasuper hard viagrastomach problems associated with viagrais viagra available in jamaicapropolene diet pill side effectsherb that acts like viagraviagra knock offs do they workwhat problems are there buying viagra in australiagenerische viagra 100mg price eurowhere in canada can i buy over the counter viagraviagra post officeis viagra covered by green sheild insurancebrand name viagra discountpowered by vbulletin national socialist movementhow long sildenafil 50 lastCialis 20mg Washingtoncialis pay paipallbuy clomid online no prescription in the ukcheapest viagra 100 forhow many mg of strattera to get highcan i buy powder amoxicillinviagra for women nzcialis super express deliveryherbal viagra review ukside effects from womens viagrageneric version of avodartciprofloxacin can be bought at mercury druglevitra how long to waithow long to wait for cialiscialis medication from indiapunishment for buying viagrais cialis otc in canada storeszithromax one dose for sinusitisamoxicillin 500 mg not workingdo i need a prescription for cialis at kaiser4 days after zoloft increaseca you up your 5mg daily cialis dosecost of celebrex at walmartgeneric viagra 2 dayklonopin lexapro drug interactionbuy diflucan onlinequetiapine generic canadadiltiazem cialiswere can i get a free sample of viagratadalafil uputstvo na srpskomdoes viagra guarantee an erection and for how longwhere can i buy viagra in los angelesdo animals take viagrabuy viagra online legitimateescitalopram in the uk buyphenergan suppository overdoseviagra for men at walmartcan you buy viagra from canadacan i bring viagra on flight without prescriptionbuying cialis via pay pallthyroxine bodybuilding dosehow does nifedipine workviagra patient information sheeturdu books about viagraabisoprolol and tadalafilhow much viagra is it safe ti takeamoxicillin 500 without prescriptionprice viagra droppedcialis watermeloncialis greeksildenafil vi need to find diet pills with ephedradose hcl propranololplavix works clotting cascadehow long will cialis keep me hardclomiphene citrate sales statistics in indiacvs levitra pricewhich insurance company covers cialischeap viagra se5how much are antibiotics in stop and shopwhere can i buy generic viagra with paypalcialis 40 mg erectile dysfunctionhow long for thrush to go away after taking diflucando flex plans cover viagracialis tadalafilcanadaclomid where to buy ukprescription lamisil cure herpescialis 30day pricewhat is singulair 10mg tablets for bronchitishow many times can you cum while using viagrawhere can i get cialis over the counterviagra within 24hrsovernight viagra delivery in the usafree erectile dysfunction pillsbuy strattera ciplawill viagra give me a harder erectionviagra cialis philippinesuk viagra patentadderall viagra back painthe guys actors of cialis commercialslow dose propranolol pregnancyhow to buy levitra wiht out perscriptiontadalafil citrate 20 mgbuy ranbaxy lipitor in india onlinefirst time taking viagraviagra work animation youtubecan i take viagra through my rectum wiil it workviagra molecular formulaviagra erection nois original viagra available in lahore pakistandoes mixing cialis with roxicodone affect your libidoblue cross viagrawhy was i told to take cialis after prostate surgerycan cialis give yeast infectiondose metronidazole cream affect menwhat is seroquel high likeviagra discount pricesdoes viagra helps erectionseroquel next dayside affect in dogs with prednisone 20mg twice per day

Jump to content


Photo

Interesting Conversation


  • Please log in to reply
74 replies to this topic

#41 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:12 AM

According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Cop out.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Not a cop out to them. If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating. I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The rosh is only concerned with learning torah working is not a reason not to fast.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#42 Psychodad

Psychodad

    88

  • Members
  • 7,376 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:14 AM

.

#43 Tova

Tova

    Godol Hador

  • Members
  • 3,230 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:15 AM

According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Cop out.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Not a cop out to them. If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating. I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The rosh is only concerned with learning torah working is not a reason not to fast.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

What's the rosh's opinion of women fasting?
If they're getting off for the second seder, then why can't they fast? (It's like a half-day-- yeshiva kids who go to school and presumably learn and are over bar/bat mitzvah fast, correct?)
Do they have a big breakfast? Or something small, simply to sustain themselves?
So little room, so much to say!
The day will come when I will be able to properly and fully express myself in my sig. Today is a sad day.

#44 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:18 AM

The rosh is only concerned with learning torah working is not a reason not to fast.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Who hires these people?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Good question

According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Cop out.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Not a cop out to them. If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating. I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The rosh is only concerned with learning torah working is not a reason not to fast.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

What's the rosh's opinion of women fasting?
If they're getting off for the second seder, then why can't they fast? (It's like a half-day-- yeshiva kids who go to school and presumably learn and are over bar/bat mitzvah fast, correct?)
Do they have a big breakfast? Or something small, simply to sustain themselves?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

This particular yeshiva does not give off second seder. Thats the point-the yeshiva wants them learning every seder. In normal yeshivos where guys fast they get off for second seder.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#45 accolade

accolade

    probably doesn't care

  • Members
  • 10,776 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:18 AM

Not a cop out to them.  If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating.  I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Why?
דעלך סני לחברך לא תעביד

#46 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:20 AM

Not a cop out to them.  If they hold one must learn because chayav in talmud torah and its deoraysah and the guys cant learn without eating.  I//m not saying I agree just explaining their logic.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Why?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I just understand that a guy would not be able to learn well without eating. they need strength. I agree they need to eat to learn a whole day. I don't agree that they don't have to fast so that they could learn.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#47 accolade

accolade

    probably doesn't care

  • Members
  • 10,776 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:24 AM

I just understand that a guy would not be able to learn well without eating.  they need strength.  I agree they need to eat to learn a whole day.  I don't agree that they don't have to fast so that they could learn.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think they're deluding themselves and that, in most cases, they'd find wellsprings of strength they didn't know they had until they tried fasting and learning. I feel similarly about women/girls who claim to be too weak to fast with no basis.
דעלך סני לחברך לא תעביד

#48 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:26 AM

I just understand that a guy would not be able to learn well without eating.  they need strength.  I agree they need to eat to learn a whole day.  I don't agree that they don't have to fast so that they could learn.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think they're deluding themselves and that, in most cases, they'd find wellsprings of strength they didn't know they had until they tried fasting and learning. I feel similarly about women/girls who claim to be too weak to fast with no basis.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You are wrong- a guy can't fast a whole day and learn a whole day.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#49 accolade

accolade

    probably doesn't care

  • Members
  • 10,776 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 11:27 AM

You are wrong- a guy can't fast a whole day and learn a whole day.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Okay.
דעלך סני לחברך לא תעביד

#50 rashi613

rashi613

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 778 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:01 PM

His rosh yeshiva and the Brisker rav in eretz yisroel hold yeshiva guys don't fast because talmid torah is deoraysa and fasting is deranbanan.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I really don't see why they have to be mutually exclusive. :unsure:

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Additionally, there's not neccessarily a problem with an Issur D'rabbanan pushing off a mitvas aseh min haTorah. Think, for example, why don't we blow shofar when Rosh hashana falls out on Shabbos? Shofar is an aseh min hatorah and carrying is an issur d'rabbanan!!

#51 Daniel

Daniel

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 785 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:09 PM

You are wrong- a guy can't fast a whole day and learn a whole day.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Sure you can. On YK you spend a 25 hours fasting and davening. You tell me that fasting 25 hours and also having kavanah in your tefilos all day is possible, but fasting 12 hours and just learning isn't? :D

Sorry, these Brisker guys are real weaklings, if you ask me.

#52 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:10 PM

You are wrong- a guy can't fast a whole day and learn a whole day.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Sure you can. On YK you spend a 25 hours fasting and davening. You tell me that fasting 25 hours and also having kavanah in your tefilos all day is possible, but fasting 12 hours and just learning isn't? :D

Sorry, these Brisker guys are real weaklings, if you ask me.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Since I'm not a guy I can't swear by it but learning gemara takes the most energy more than davening. You don't have to think too much too daven as you do to learn.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#53 enigma

enigma

    רבנית

  • Members
  • 3,070 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:30 PM

I think they're deluding themselves and that, in most cases, they'd find wellsprings of strength they didn't know they had until they tried fasting and learning. I feel similarly about women/girls who claim to be too weak to fast with no basis.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

This bothers me as well. Before I started working, I never knew how many women don't fast, but now I'm sitting here hungry and half the office is munching. <_< :(
אין הדבר תלוי אלא בי

"Have you seen H&M this season? It looks like the 70's threw up on the 80's." ~holy

#54 Moshi

Moshi

    Little Reb Sunshine

  • Members
  • 21,046 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:36 PM

That is f-d up. They can't learn well without eating, but I'm supposed to sit here thirsty, hungry, with a splitting headache and write computer code?

Forget it, I'm going downstairs to get lunch.

:angry:
The L-rd may not come when you call, but He's always on time. -Lemon Andersen

Kabel et ha-emet mi-mi she-omro.

"All is by the hand of Heaven, except colds and fevers" -Ketubot 30a.

~My Blog~

#55 myaccountname

myaccountname

    Rebbe

  • Members
  • 1,209 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:38 PM

This newly married Brisker guy comes home one fast day after shachris and asks his wife for breakfast, she looks at him :wacko: arent you fasting today? No, he answers, I need to learn all day and can't do it when I'm fasting. So being a good wife she makes him a nice breakfast and sits down to eat with him. What are you doing, he asked? Eating with you she answered. No, you can't do that, we're not machmir on the women!
Thats why there is caramel and vanilla...

#56 Daniel

Daniel

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 785 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:44 PM

This newly married Brisker guy comes home one fast day after shachris and asks his wife for breakfast, she looks at him  :wacko: arent you fasting today? No, he answers, I need to learn all day and can't do it when I'm fasting. So being a good wife she makes him a nice breakfast and sits down to eat with him. What are you doing, he asked? Eating with you she answered. No, you can't do that, we're not machmir on the women!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


:D :D :D

#57 prototype

prototype

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 261 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 12:59 PM


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

what about a non-pregnant non-nursing mother with small children to care for?

#58 skifree

skifree

    smoothie queen

  • Members
  • 3,440 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 01:03 PM


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

what about a non-pregnant non-nursing mother with small children to care for?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

No heter for that.
I am sigless and smoothieless thanks to the mods

#59 Guest_melech_*

Guest_melech_*
  • Guests

Posted 10 January 2006 - 01:04 PM

.

#60 myaccountname

myaccountname

    Rebbe

  • Members
  • 1,209 posts

Posted 10 January 2006 - 01:09 PM


According to this guy that told me this-guys need to eat to learn.  They need strength.  It is hard to learn a whole day without eating.  Yeshivos give off second seder normally on fasts.  This rosh holds they should learn and therefor need to eat to shteig.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Alrighty then what about the work force-- the working people who have to run up and down the stairs at the subway, dart through tourists on the street and work a full day shouldn't need energy to perform at their best? Shteiging doesn't burn calories.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

what about a non-pregnant non-nursing mother with small children to care for?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

No heter for that.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Depends whom you ask. Ask Mindy.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


agree with melech

the Bobover Ruv ZT"L was very maikel with regards to fasting even for bucherim even on tisha b'av
Thats why there is caramel and vanilla...




1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users