artscroll, on Feb 15 2006, 01:44 PM, said:
I mean, you sound close to saying that TSHBP is really what Chazal determined, not what Chazal received.
Very interesting post, BTW.
In this matter I hold like the Rambam, who says that anythng about which there is a machloket within our Mesorah is not torah l'moshe misinai. Thus, anything that there's an argument about is an accretion of halacha to the system - a piece of OT created by Chazal. I'm also comfortable with the Ramban's position that Hashem gave Moshe every argument and told him to have the Sanhedrin sort out halacha l'maseh.

Sign In
Register
Help


MultiQuote



