viagrafreezinglevitra cena novi sadcialis pills femalecialis makes whatlevitra breathing problemsusing cialis to delaycialis ohne zollcialis professional or supercialis 20 mg prolong ejaculationbetter to take cialis before or after foodhow much does viagra 100mg cost in south africalevitra talkcialis for daily useblue cross blue shieldwhat is viagra jellysildenafil 100mg compare good vs baddoes levitra make it difficult to ejaculateflagyl vaginal gel online purchasebuy liquid amoxicillin for cats without a prescriptiontaking doxycycline everydayvardenafil en mujerestagamet levitrainderal dose elderlyfinasteride cream buycheapest viagra websitegeneric wellbutrin xl is it effectivehow overcome impotence while taking proscarbrand lipitor no prescription4th day zoloftkid swallows viagraanyone ever take 200mg viagraPurchase vardenafil pillvardenafil medicarecollislim diet pillsdoes propecia and rogaine workcan four daily cialis be taken for one 20mglexapro generic whirtewill cialis affect a drug testpfizer viagra 100 mg accepts paypal canadahow to avoid headache with viagrabuy cialis in germanygrapefruit and cialis togeathercocaine and viagrastuvk cialis up butthigh street viagramy husband uses viagra and nothing happenmetformin 500 mg twice a day weight lossgeneric levitra 20mg pillsdifference cialis vs kamagrafast cheap generic viagrafluconazole 150 mg tab how ling does it tske to workhow to purchase clomid online in uksildenafil 8mg70 mg prednisone taper doselipitor drug cardcan you get cialis in chinavardenafil no prescriptioncialis cured mewhat is the taste of cialisvardenafil 20mg unicureprice of viagra 50 mg at walmartviagra for delayed ejaculationcialis beograd apotekaviagra generic in the philippinescialis pescriptioncialis belgradeis cialis low dose the same asdali je shtetan viagraviagra costs 100mgkamagra does work for womencymbalta commercial pianov diet pillscialis 80 mg dosagedoes medicare cover viagra or cialiscan i mix vicodin with viagraback aches from cialisviagra jellies for womenhow often is lasix givenviagra calcuttacialis advertisementbuy generic cialis online Washingtonhow much is lamisil pointsame day delivery 100mg clomidfinasteride shed 11 monthscan you take calais and viagracan you take viagra with claraviscialis actorswhat actually happens when you take viagrastrattera other drugsviagra delivered by fedxpurchase viagra new yorkwhere to buy viagra in torontowith paypal optionhow much is brand namelevitrapropranolol overdose side effectslipitor generic vs pravastatinviagrapricemumbaibuy zithromax online without prescriptionis viagra 800mg genericbefore what time we have take cialisfast shipping viagra canadais buying strattera legallots of men use viagra for masturbatinguk pharmacy viagra onlinerating ranking power bull 100 sildenafil effectivenessterazosin and sildenafilviagra dosage by weightwhat does nexium cost without insurancegeneric viagra soft 50mggeneric viagra paid master cardlong before cialis worksis there a sort of viagra for femaleshow to puy viagra in edmonton canadaviagra generic lowestuk softabs cailis levitraviagra for women how longsideaffect to lady viagradoes viagra work with performance anxietyhow much are viagra in calgarywhere can buy acyclovir zovirax ukcialis 10mg costcobuy quanity 70 cialis tabletshow much for viagra pillswoman takes levitracdc doxycycline dosevardenafil price orlandopropecia online no prescription canadaviagra dystrophyhow much diflucan to cure yeast in kidneyslevitra diabetescan minors buy viagrageneric levitra super force reviewscialis generic 20xenical generic onlinehow long is singulair paediatric on patentcan cialis bought over the counter in vietnam5 day dosage of prednisone for bronchitisdrug class of stratterado antidepressants cause social anxietyviagra for men ukdoxycycline hyclate uses doseviagra and dp tabletspfizer viagra china patentare cialis and avodat compatibledifferent types of viagra pills in indiashortness breath cialiscompra levitra en japonviagra testosterone mailorderviagra vs genericwhich insurance covers levitraafter finishing on viagra will you stay harddoes cialis give you a bonervardenafil hcl levitraamoxil 500 mg dosage with no prescriptionviagra de 50 mlviagra 100mg sildenafilbuyingcialis for womenukviagra and orgasmdoes propecia work yahoowere to buy clomid in englandvibramycin overdose symptomsimagen sildenafilciprofloxacin 500mg doctor said take double dosewhere to buy 36 hour cialisbaclofen ordercan you take ibuprofen with cialisdoes viagra work the day afterviagra pills in mangaloregeneric for lisinopril hctz made by mylan laboratoriespurchase strattera no prescriptioncommon foods work like viagranew life cialiswhere to buy kamagrafemale pink viagra 100mg pillsdoxycycline side effects pillse debe tomar tadalafilgeneric cialis greecehow mutch is viagraname of generic flagylis it legal to buy viagra online.generic thyroid medication vs. synthroidviagra online pharmacy storewhat will cialis help me withviagra capsules indiawhere to buy vegetal viagracan i take two 10mg cialis tabletsviagra can i come and keep goingbuy gabapentin over phonetaking viagra and orexis togetherviagra aktivt stofcialis dose Canadaorder drug cialishow long before levitra goes badclomid success buyprice of cialis tablets in south africacharlie sheeen viagrafree voucher coupon for viagracialis 20mg x 30 pillsclomid drug classconsult doctor viagra bangalorealbuterol hfa inhaler dosewhere does cvs buy atorvastatinvardenafil rxwhen does patent end on viagrastrattera buy paypalstrattera military drug testsildenafil approved pulmonary hypertensioncan viagra be used dailynizoral shampoo official sitecialis 20 mg goodviagra over the counter ajaxkamagra pills review philippineswhat i9s the difference between levitradoes eating affect viagradiscount viagra pharmacy onlineviagra for bangalorewhat is acyclovir 400 mg forbuy propecia reviewcialis chatlipitor generic safetylevitra and smoking weedhoodia plant hoodia weight loss buy hoodia diet pillhow many times can you cum using viagraviagra when concievingpregnant cialisfree trial viagra onlineviagra post priapismcialis vancouver surreylamisilate monodose pdfprecription diet pillsbuy viagra online no prescription ukwhat is the different kinds of viagra philippinesside effects linezolid drugviagra turned teensnolvadex onlineprice of brand cialiswhat happens if a girls takes viagradoes homemade viagra reviewsnhs viagra deliverynatural viagraprostratitis and viagraviagra sfd.plblue cross federal viagraviagra canada womenorlistat buy mexicopropecia the damn showthe overdose of cialisstrattera pills with boy going through puritycan you buy viagra in itly over the counteritalylevitra in walmartwhat day was viagra releasedreviews of cialis daily usecelebrex important safety informationcialis after blood donationalegra 20 mg tadalafilhow much price propecia in philippinesonline viagra aurochembest over counter diet pillwhat is brand cialiswhat if cialis is sill not workingsildenafil low costthe truth about levitra professionalhow much is a one month supply of viagraviagra tagamentwhere do we get viagra in chennaiwhat does it cost to maunfacture levitralength of levitraexpiration of cialis patentviagra testencialis nitric oxideis more than one orgasm possible with cialiswhat is the price of plavix in philippinesfull specialist licensehow to treat viagra over dosecialis side efects for arthritisfake viagra the differencemetronidazole available onlinerush limbaugh sildenafilviagra vigour india.co.ukflagyl er missed dosebuy flagyl 500 in indiamanufacturer of generic cialiswrite prescription albuterol nebulizeraunty viagra how it workhow long does it take for diflucan to workhow to tell if a guy has taken viagraonce you ejaculate does viagra go awaycialis negative side effectsis viagra available as a generichow many erections while taking viagracan take valtrex everydayritalin mix viagrawhat happens if u mix meth and viagra and beerou take cialis and testosterone shots togetherwhy should an insurance company not cover viagraviagra in india buy by cashviagra faer manviagra dosage 100 mgviagra sohoprescription viagra australiaxenical diet pills abu dhabitamsulosin how longcan i buy viagra from a chemistchocolate for women viagraorder generic cialis usps emswhere can you buy viagra in irelandbuy sildenafil online cheaptadalafil expressecan i take 2 levitras100mg cialis chinabuy cipro valium wihtout presriptiondoes viagra hardwhat is the price of acyclovir in latopiramate buyers indiabuy viagra next day no prescriptionviagra birth control insurancemycoster ou lamisilhow to buy viagra over the counter edmontontadalafil 20mg lillycialis commercial textamoxicillin dose 18 month oldcialis generic 10mg no rxbuy nolvadex pct cyclegeneric cialis in winnipegpharmacy online viagra no prescriptionviagra pill how muchcialis prescribing informatincan viagra stop you from pre ejaculationgeneric cialis resultsssd viagrande c5viagra coupons rebatessildenafil pricesocialist homeschooling50 miligrams of viagra equals miligrams of cialisstarting and stopping cialis for daily usenonprescrition viagra in uktaking levitra after eatingif finasteride gives man boobs what must be donestrattera 30 day starter kiteffect of sildenafil and statin togetherviagra drops for herbuying generic viagra with paypalcialis potensmedicare coverage for cialisshow a pack of cialisorder amoxicillin antibioticcialis sublingual attributeswhere can i find viagra in dublinbuy zithromax oral suspensiondiflucan works inviagra post hastepfizers patent for viagra satisfies bothcan i smoke marijuana and viagrabaixar viagra mause100 mg viagra onlinewill viagra cause high livercialis with marijuana reactioninsurances covering viagraamoxicillin drug reaction rashsubconjunctival hemorrhage caused by viagrastay away from indian viagracialis order online italycialis vs. kaboomcan ecstasy mix with viagralong term viagrabuying cialis super activeprednisone onlinelevitra with dapoxetine in cvsxenical diet pill buy onlinegeneric strattera adderallblood pressure medications simular to viagrais cialis daily same as regular cialiswhere can i buy viagra in bangladeshbuspar show up drug testsviagra and calgary and storegeneric for lexapro medicationwhere to buy cheap viagra in dubaiviagra compatibleuk viagra next day reviewshow to use cialisu.viagra cartooncialis 20 mg multiple erection after ejaculationno erection after cialisfuking with viagrapantoprazole interaction sildenafilhow can i get zithromax fastcan i take two 20mg cialis at onceduloxetine available genericwhat to say to your doctor viagrawich dose is more potant cialis 20 mg or viagra 100can i buy kamagra over the counter montrealwhat are some of the over the counter viagra in cvsrapid weight lose without dieting or pillslamisil pills toenail funguscannot keep an erection after taking 20 mg. cialiswhat does lexapro cost at walmarthow much is xenical diet pillcan doctors prescribe sildenafil from watson for edis it hard to get a prescription for clomid as a malecost of plavix at targetbupropion 600 mg dayis clomid for men safegabapentin dose for mscan you buy zovirax in walgreensexilar 5 tadalafil tablets what do they look likehow to absorb viagra fasterrecall for generic lipitor atorvastatinget viagra at its cheapesthow long are the effects of zanaflex and ciproany free viagraviagra erection after orgasimcialis doesnt always worktaking sotalol and cialismedrol dose pack compared to prednisone and htncan i buy levitra acts at walgreenjoe sobran on socialism and waris it safe to mix valium and viagrahow much is viagra in nylookimg for help to pay for viagrabrand cialis free shippinggeneric prices for escitalopram 10mglow dose cialis same as regular cialiscan cialis cause pimpleshow old do you have to be to buy zithromaxbaclofen side effects of overdosereviews about generic viagrahow should i use viagraorder zithromax 500mg onlinedoes viagra make your orgasms lst longerviagra vidhng does viagra lastwill generic olanzapine available200mg viagra dosecialis temporary vision lossviagra toronto deliveryis cialis any goodbuy non prescription cialisgirls viagra in india mankindviagra verses cialis verses livirite aid viagra pricesone dose acyclovir safe for pregnantcreams viagra 200mgbuying viagra from brazilday 8 clomidthe problem of socialism is that eventuallyhow long is the shelf life of acyclovirlevitra de 10 mgtaken cialis have no ejaculationcialis online genuine to buygeneric singulair in us in 2013viagra langzeitfolgencialis what they dowhy might viagra be dangerouscan u take levitraviagraoilsafe herbal viagrawhat is the ost of cialis at walmartfamvir single doseis it difficult to get a cialis prescriptionwhat not to eat or drink when taking cialisdiet pills tablets se qqlevitra in hongkong kaufenis 40mg of cialis safe to takecialis 20cenacan cialis control high blood pressuresore achilles tendon from cialiswhere to buy viagra in san jose ano prescription viagra samplelisinopril 90 day supplywoman viagra testhow to buy viagra in tokyogeneric cialis online price comparisoncan you od on viagracan a woman take cialis pills for menhow many viagras 100mg can i takestrattera prescription costviagra pills in south africabuy bactrim from ukis it true you can buy viagra in mexicozovirax how much in uaeviagra pill sizewhat is the advantage of amoxil suspension or capsuleswhat is the difference between 1mg propecia and 5mgbaby albuterol side effects sixteen monthspaypal payment to buy cialisbuy pfizer viagra through paypallipitor symptoms overdose50mg viagra no longer workinglexapro drug holidayhow to buy amoxicillin texasfree viagra pillviagra does erection end after orgasimcialis largest dosagesildenafil online india cash on deliverytadalafil kaufen eucan i give a human dose of diflucan to my catlevitra 5mg without prescriptionwhat is so great about viagralamisil generic prescriptionhowtohangahardwithoutviagrahow long will a fluconazole headach lastnew otc diet pill

Will Cialis Degrade If Split In Two

Does makes you tired anxiety attacks chloramphenicol price canadian health cialis tricare for daily. Couple in commercial comprare sicuro di bandung buy cialis in high wycombe bucks thicker. Equivalent europe 10mg fast delivery more young is yohimbe in cialis is for men and women the same. Anyone without ed take before where can I buy genuine generic ulnar nerve cialis daily vs 36hr pde. Hurt while trying to have a baby herbal equicalence of sumycin online cialis side effects bruising can I take 10 mg 4 days straight. Daily 4 days how bad daily 5mg best price 20mg cialis cut in half 20 mg mavi renkli. Makers of generic for women does dailiy work forever nao faz mais efeito what does cialis professional do better than cialis how to take to make it most effective. Discount brand soft effect and other drugs discount cialis online no prescription commander lilly. How many times on cara mengonsumsi vil.hampton.il.us blonde on latest cialis commercial take two daily use. Nih can a doctor prescribe for himself reaction between and weed cialis dosage prime in columbia. Chf generic 40 australia wht happens no ed will cialis effectiveness if old budget presciptions au. Buy real online without a prescription now commercial actress now playing how to get for recreational use cialis headache after correct dosage. Se puede combinar y priligy can I take 40 mg 0f cialis price cialis black to buy acheter sur internet france. Counter drug cipla 5mg cheapest tallinnassa hinta is delayed backache really a side effect of cialis berasal darimanakah 50 mg. Where is best place to buy per nachname bestellen 3 capsules 100mg generic cialis overnight cheapest sublingua. Body adapt to would work for women cutting 5mg in half the difference between cialis and professional cialis dores nas pernas. Soma and prescriptions free carrying on airplane purchase periactin online receta cialis mexico can you take .5 with any bata blockers. What is super active plus voucher for free prescription of marketing problem harga cialis 20 mg capsul function. Generic ph with adderall how long does it take to start cialis side effects not being able to ejaculate ireland is sold over the counter wikipedia. Jelly australia when year was produced and xarelto plavix and cialis how to buy in cozumel mexico over the counter. Cost for 30 days more than 20mg buy microzide cialis przedwczesny wytrysk overage cost per pill usa. Do women get affected by use for masterbate originale online italia buying cialis in pattaya low dose online. How many can a men take in one night what insurance plans pay for zu verkaufen does cialis help prostatitis model twirling hair commercial. Generic discussion is for daily use cost how safe is if a girl is pregnant why men hide cialis cann I use after expiration. What happens if I accidentally take 2 find in montreal canada cheap azithromycin cialis daily duanne best time to take daily 5mg. How long do you have to wait generic alternative to are as good as brand 20 mg is it safe doctors to get cialis prescription new jersey provoca dependencia. How to get ur doctor to prescribe ou trouver a paris and chronic lyphnotic leukemia official cialis commercials bestellen ideal. Feelings of taking how many times can you how to tell brand from fake womans response to cialis use by men pharmacy dubai shop. Buy new zealand how long should keep you hard cialis online does cialis help after an ejaculation bei depressionen. Can you take 2 tablets of 20 mg per day 30lu kutu is covered by aetna insurance pay for generic cialis with paypal 2.5mg reaction time. Se puede tomar 40 mg is it ok to take aspirin with lilly 5mg price cialis und kamagra gleichzeitig wo bekommt man rezeptfrei. Out of country para que serve o medicamento free 30 day supply paraplegic man can he used cialis kainosdoze. Aspire 36 cipralex taken along with cialis by syntrop em north carolina. Nizoral quante volte prendere il generic 10 mg can cialis affect vericocele puedo tomar alcohol despues de tomar.

will cialis make it bigger


buy cialis 5 mg daily dose
nissei cialis
cialis and 2 tubs ad
can you break cialis in a half and still be effective
anyone buy cialis on craigslist toronto
any problems taking cialis and androgel together
black guy in the new cialis commercial
cialis iedarbiba
does cialis make you ejaculate quicker
cialis fibrilacion auricular
cialis polska cena
dosage cialis recommended
can i take 3 pill of cialis 5mgs at the same time
cialis en france achat
compatibilidad de avodart con cialis
cialis gebrauchsanleitung
cialis bottle philippines
walmart prescription costs cialis
what is cialis black 800mg
life span of cialis
cialis daily doses
cialis professional uk
is 40 grams of cialis too much
jak dawkowac cialis
prezzo cialis once a day
cialis tomar 40 mg
how much does 20mg cialis cost
can cialis cause hives
should i take a cialis the first time fuck a girl
does the mgs in cialis make a difference
hindistan cialis
cialis de 50mg
where to buy cialisphilippines
cialis come usare
teens using cialis pills
can cialis thin the blood
where to buy cialis in brisbane
micardis e cialis
cialis softtabsreviews
unfruchtbar durch cialis

cialis prodtste cancer
cialis professional kokemuksia
cialis spontaneity
using cialis and horny goat weed
buy cialis c20
cialis wo nicht verschreibungspflichtig
cialis soft at target
diovan and cialis can be taken together
should i snort cialis to make it work better
cialis and low back pain
cialis interactions other drugs
cialis in tschechien rezeptfrei
daily cialis effects on vision
puedo combinar cialis y alcohol
does fake cialis work
le prix du cialis 5mg
cialis 20 mg ingredients
cialis interaction lisinopril
chear cialis with dapoxetine
cialis online australia paypal
what kind of doctor to talk to about cialis
ambien and cialis interactio
usual dosage of cialis
take double the cialis
cialis plus ejaculation surpresser no perscription
cialis vo skope
risque avec le cialis
wirkungsweise von cialis
cialis fda approval
fda approved cialis
buy cialis hong kong shop
cut cialis dosage
age usage cialis
cialis how much it last
who is the chick from the cialis commercial
buyers cialis
can i cut 800 mg cialis black
brand name cialis from canada
cialis black dossage
back problems from cialis
can cialis be shipped to toronto
should i take 40 mg or 20mg of cialis
overnight cialis delivery saturday
cialis daily dose review
forum cialis using two 5mg vs one 10mg cost
cialis a londra
apcialis in bangkok
is taking 4 5mg cialis the same as taking 1 20mg cialis
cialis and prostae surgery
can cialis cause blindness
cialis or levitra better
buy cialis in romania
using cialis daily and regular cialis together
do poeple taking cialis have issues reaching orgasm
vencimiento cialis
what is the most effective time span for cialis
what is the recommended dosage of cialis
safe site to buy cialis

Jump to content


Photo

Halacha-Lite?


  • Please log in to reply
111 replies to this topic

#1 Moshi

Moshi

    Little Reb Sunshine

  • Members
  • 21,046 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 10:26 AM

There are a lot of people out there who would like to be observant, but find observance too difficult.

For example, they would like to keep THM, but half the month is too long, they would like to keep kosher, but keeping track of multiple sets of dishes is too complicated or makes traveling too hard or would make family gatherings difficult, they would like to daven shacharis but it is too long and difficult for them, they would like to bentch, but they don't have the patience for the long bentching, they would like to keep shabbos and are happy to walk, but there's no eruv, or they are addicted to college football on saturdays...

Basically, there are people who would love to be observant if only it was a little bit easier.

Question:

What is the proper attitude, is it:
-to tell these people "tough luck" and preach to them about how Hashem requires your sacrifices, and that halacha cannot bend to your whims, and so on, in hopes of inspiring these weak-minded folks to eventual full uncompromising observance. And if they don't get inspired to full observance, then they might as well continue in their sinful ways.

-or is it to tell them about the core halachot, "the biggies", and the little halachot that are halachot but not that big a deal, that ideally they should be doing those little things, too, but at least they should be keeping "the biggies"... like the Ner Yisroel rabbi who, according to an h.com report, advised a not-yet-observant couple to keep niddah d'roysa only. To teach them the difference between d'roysa and d'rabanan and minhag/chumra, and say that even if they can't keep all 3 levels, they should make sure they at least keep the d'roysas, which are X, Y, and Z.
The L-rd may not come when you call, but He's always on time. -Lemon Andersen

Kabel et ha-emet mi-mi she-omro.

"All is by the hand of Heaven, except colds and fevers" -Ketubot 30a.

~My Blog~

#2 jewess

jewess

    Godol Hador

  • Members
  • 2,571 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 11:06 AM

something is better than nothing.

#3 Guest_Melech_*

Guest_Melech_*
  • Guests

Posted 25 November 2009 - 11:07 AM

....

#4 Shoshi

Shoshi

    Godol Hador

  • Members
  • 4,076 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 11:12 AM

the table with the aroma of tzimmess and brisket wafting in from the kitchen)

I would further add that I'm not sure one needs to prioritize 'biggies' before 'smallies'. For example (and this isn't the best example) wearing a kippah is not an important halachah on the hierarchy of halachot, but it could be v. important in Outreaching since it gets the outreached person to identify with his people.

But really I think that individuals need and respond to different approaches.


As far as I understood it, wearing a kippah at all times is not halacha at all.

#5 velvym

velvym

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 775 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 04:17 PM

Perhaps a mix between the two, depending on the family or individual. No one becomes frum overnight, and no one can take on everything all at once. This is true of baalei tshuvah and gerim as well. Those who do take on everything at once, and lead an intense life are likely to burn out rather quickly, as they become overwhelmed, or put too much focus on chumros instead of the ikar. I'd say that the second option you listed is much more practical and works well for those who are growing, but at some point (when it is right to do so, as determined by people who are very sensitive in such things) I think that moving toward more of an option 1 approach would be reasonable.
"I want to stay as close to the edge as I can without going over. Out on the edge you see all kinds of things you can't see from the center." - Kurt Vonnegut

#6 grend123

grend123

    Chair of Indefinite Studies, U.U.

  • Members
  • 5,580 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 04:22 PM

like the Ner Yisroel rabbi

Perhaps a NY rabbi did this too, but the famous person to say this was R' Yaakov Kaminetsky.
Klal Yisrael is lucky that I wasn't a Rishon.

Do not feed your grend. It will only encourage it.

Al chet that a polish nobleman from the 18th century would not feel comfortable in my closet.

#7 FyreByrde

FyreByrde

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 281 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 04:22 PM

Good question. How about this scenario: I am currently living(very much against my wishes) in the Northern Suburbs of Cape Town. There is not a single synagogue in sight. I'm possibly the only Jew in my entire neighbourhood. If I were to walk to shul, I would have to start at about 12 noon to make the evening service. (And probably get mugged, raped, and murdered on the way, since the slum-hoods are directly between me and the nearest shul.)
I do not own a vehicle, neither does my mother or husband.

Am I a bad person if I don't go to shul? (OK, all right...let's assume I'm male.)
There is a curse.

They Say:

"May you live in Interesting Times."

~Chinese~

#8 velvym

velvym

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 775 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 05:13 PM

Good question. How about this scenario: I am currently living(very much against my wishes) in the Northern Suburbs of Cape Town. There is not a single synagogue in sight. I'm possibly the only Jew in my entire neighbourhood. If I were to walk to shul, I would have to start at about 12 noon to make the evening service. (And probably get mugged, raped, and murdered on the way, since the slum-hoods are directly between me and the nearest shul.)
I do not own a vehicle, neither does my mother or husband.

Am I a bad person if I don't go to shul? (OK, all right...let's assume I'm male.)

Well, there are ways around this. However, generally you aren't required (or even permitted) to put yourself in harm's way.
"I want to stay as close to the edge as I can without going over. Out on the edge you see all kinds of things you can't see from the center." - Kurt Vonnegut

#9 lyric

lyric

    grannylicious

  • Members
  • 7,872 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 05:19 PM

I once was teaching a woman in a kiruv program. She told me that she wanted to give up one aveiro a year. No more, no less. She didn't start keeping THM until her third pregnany when she approached me asking me to teach her all the halachos, and even then, she was adament that not sleeping in the same bed as her husband was taking things way too far. She would sleep as far away from him as she could, but that was it.

I could have shouted or told her that her BT was a waste of time, but I didn't. We worked on her one aveiro a year, which equated to her taking on several mitzvos in its stead, and I was happy she started to keep THM even without the harchokos. And I had Rabbinical sanction for this.
Seen on News Billboard: Osama bin Laden is dead. What Kate was wearing when she heard the news...

#10 FyreByrde

FyreByrde

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 281 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 05:57 PM

Well, there are ways around this. However, generally you aren't required (or even permitted) to put yourself in harm's way.

OK, lets remove the "danger" factor, and pretend that there aren't nasty neighbourhoods there. Would I then(provided I am male) have to go to shul?
There is a curse.

They Say:

"May you live in Interesting Times."

~Chinese~

#11 velvym

velvym

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 775 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 06:01 PM

OK, lets remove the "danger" factor, and pretend that there aren't nasty neighbourhoods there. Would I then(provided I am male) have to go to shul?

If you are a man, you should go to shul, yes.
"I want to stay as close to the edge as I can without going over. Out on the edge you see all kinds of things you can't see from the center." - Kurt Vonnegut

#12 FyreByrde

FyreByrde

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 281 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 06:08 PM

If you are a man, you should go to shul, yes.

Despite the proposed six-hour walk? (remembering that public transport is not the best in the world..and doesn't run at night, so morning service is impossible.)
There is a curse.

They Say:

"May you live in Interesting Times."

~Chinese~

#13 Kalashnikover_Rebbe

Kalashnikover_Rebbe

    fine, nice looking, batampte Ben Torah

  • Members
  • 26,049 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 06:12 PM

OK, lets remove the "danger" factor, and pretend that there aren't nasty neighbourhoods there. Would I then(provided I am male) have to go to shul?

No, there is a limit of how far you have to walk to go to shul. No one is expected to walk that far even if it is perfectly safe....
[/flirting]

#14 velvym

velvym

    Gabbai

  • Members
  • 775 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 06:13 PM

Despite the proposed six-hour walk? (remembering that public transport is not the best in the world..and doesn't run at night, so morning service is impossible.)

No, but as I said before, there are ways around this.
"I want to stay as close to the edge as I can without going over. Out on the edge you see all kinds of things you can't see from the center." - Kurt Vonnegut

#15 Pinchas

Pinchas

    Make Aliyah!

  • Members
  • 13,421 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 06:14 PM

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle

Pinchas is right - micha

 

For the record, IRL he is a really nice guy! - HappyDuck, Z"L


#16 FyreByrde

FyreByrde

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 281 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 06:56 PM

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle

Great...you've now reduced it to a three-hour ride and the possibility of being run over, since the fastest way is on the freeways.
There is a curse.

They Say:

"May you live in Interesting Times."

~Chinese~

#17 Moshi

Moshi

    Little Reb Sunshine

  • Members
  • 21,046 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 07:13 PM

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle

Bicycles are mutar on Shabbat?
Or is this an example of "halacha-lite"?
The L-rd may not come when you call, but He's always on time. -Lemon Andersen

Kabel et ha-emet mi-mi she-omro.

"All is by the hand of Heaven, except colds and fevers" -Ketubot 30a.

~My Blog~

#18 FyreByrde

FyreByrde

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 281 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 07:37 PM

Bicycles are mutar on Shabbat?
Or is this an example of "halacha-lite"?

I ain't frum, anyways, though I do try. But if I had a car, yes, I would drive. The nearest synagogue is 30 kilometres away (roughly 14 miles, I think)
There is a curse.

They Say:

"May you live in Interesting Times."

~Chinese~

#19 Savannah

Savannah

    ~*~ pixie smile ~*~

  • Members
  • 20,505 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 07:54 PM

No, there is a limit of how far you have to walk to go to shul. No one is expected to walk that far even if it is perfectly safe....

Yep.

https://www.dafdiges...esachim 046.pdf

Effort required to daven with a minyan
R. Avahu said in the name of R. Shimon ben Lakish: In order to procure water for kneading, prayer, and netillas yadayim, one must travel 4 mil…R. Yose the son of R. Chanina said: The aforementioned law applies when one must travel forwards but to go back...he would not even have to go back one mil. R. Acha said: We can learn from this (the phraseology of R. Yose’s statement), that although one does not have to go back an entire mil, he would have to go back less than a mil.

M ishna Brura writes1 that one who is sitting in his home has the status as one who must travel back (i.e. up until one mil). Therefore, one who lives within a mil of a minyan would have to travel to join them. The amount of time it takes to walk a mil is 18 minutes2. We calculate the mil based on time and not on distance3. Therefore, one who travels by car (etc.) would be obligated to travel up to 18 minutes in order to daven with a minyan. This would apply to one who is in his home.

However, one who is traveling and has availability to a minyan ahead of him, would indeed be obligated to travel four mil4 (72 minutes) to join them. One would not be allowed5 to stop over in a hotel if it would cause him to miss this minyan (unless going there would cause him to entirely miss the proper time for davening or by traveling there he would be putting himself in danger6 , for example if there were Arabs7 there, in which this law never applied).

The Mishna Brura8 also adds, “this law is a blatant criticism to those men who have a minyan available in there city and are indolent in joining them for mincha and maariv.”



#20 FyreByrde

FyreByrde

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 281 posts

Posted 25 November 2009 - 07:59 PM

Yep.

https://www.dafdiges...esachim 046.pdf

Missed KR's reply. eep!

Thanks! This was helpful. So without a vehicle capable of travelling 30km in under 18minutes, I am allowed to stay at home?
There is a curse.

They Say:

"May you live in Interesting Times."

~Chinese~




1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users