perbedaan antara cialis dan viagradoes viagra maintain erection even after orgasmafrika powerful viagrapurchase viagra in usabuy cialis lowest priceacyclovir daily dose cold sorepremature ejaculation allopathic pills tadalafillwhen taking viagra do you lose erection after comingnegative side effects viagra cialiscialist price in malaysiaviagra for preformance anxietyindiangeneric cialisbuy viagra in cape townhow to tell counterfeit viagrabuy clomid online no prescription discover cardcialis 20 directionsgeneric for maxaltwhere have sold viagraturkish viagra wikibest viagra online singaporeantidepressant drug marketshow me viagra worksviagra pfizer imitation usaemoticon de viagrapaxil works for melasix 120mg dose okaywhat is rupatadine and montelukast tablets forcan i buy zoloft over the counter in torontogeneric viagra caverta veegaviagra or levitra or cialisdiet pill ephtadalafil canada paypallevitrarecommendedcialis speeds womenwhere can i find viagra in houston txeb haus viagracost viagra cialis levitra pricescialis and caduet interaciongerman cialisdo i need 100mg of viagrawhy doesnt viagra work for me anymorelasix drug 20 mgviagra legal in swedenlevitra optimum timewill viagra get me upwill viagra make you hard after ejuculationwhat milligram do u give azithromycin for dogslamisil tablets generic price perthcialis pills ukfinding cialis in ottawacoist of viagra in the philippinesis lipitor generic nowhow much is viagra mexicobest prices on cialis in austin tx pharmacieslevitra before or after dinneri only use viagra when im with more than one womanlipitor what is the shelf lifenolvadex tabs buyhow much is viagra in nigeriacialis increased blledingpfizer viagra pune contactswhich makes your dick harder cialis or viagracialis 10mg swedenviagra cena 2011cialis phone numberscan i use tadalafil for edviagra go away after ejaculationshould teens take viagraatripla and viagra interactionviagra make ure dick biggertadalafil wikiprice viagra without insurancedoes 25 viagra worklevitra medicaltadalafili de 5mgare cipro ear drops safe for catsviagra price for mendoes 10mg cialis work wellsafe diet energy pillsantibiotics without prescriptions hawaiihow long does it take for cialis for daily use to workhub usb tadalafilowhat happens if you eat 2 year old cialishow long before others can market viagralevitra tablettariteaid price of viagrais there a generic viagra in other countrybrand name viagrabuy something like viagrachipviagra online ukwhere to buy the least expensive plavixtwo daily cialisvimax vs cialishow much does a 20 mg cialis costsildenafil eingenommenclopidogrel cost priceviagra a tesco w angliicialis euro drugstoretadalafil pack insertwhat pharmacies carry finasteride 5mg 7355montelukast generic ukdoes cialis viagra work likesildenafil pfizer 100mgcialis panvelviagra 100 cialis 20what in viagrabest gnc product like viagrahow much viagra cost each pillcialis mexico safehow many rounds cialiswhere to buy propecia tabletsdoes cialis work after prostate removaldoes viagra stop working when you ejaculatecialis par ciplalevitra use prior to surgerylevitra datasheethow long should i take bactrim forteis it safe to take viagra from indiausing my medicare to purchase cialissandoz lisinopril onlinezyvox drugbreaking up a viagracobra viagra wikicialis strength vs viagra strengthdoes walmart sell over the counter viagratell if metronidazole workinggeneric viagra discount male impotencecialis online bestellen schweizcelexa its generic equivalentpurchase lasix 12.5 for dogsviagra walmart brandwalgreens card cialiscialis adarol sickcan you get viagra at a local pharmacyviagra plus cialiscialis rebatesdoes viagra let you ejaculate multiple timescialis and prednisoneputting cialis in drinkbuy acyclovir cream australiawere can i buy viagra today in melbourneis 2 mg cialis cheaper than 20mgis viagra 100 mg too muchcan i use dapoxetine with viagrared face viagrahow to get viagra outta ones systemis generic cialis as effectivebuying viagra in tijuanadoes finasteride work on receding hairlineshalf a viagra last how longwomen viagra and ecceleratersviagra selber machenbodybuilding.com where to buy nolvadexkamagra jelly sau cialisviagra with persriptionif you ejaculate will the viagra go awaytaking viagra and zoloftcialis 5mg mxhow to ask a doctor about viagrahow much do they sell diflucan in nigeriawhat happens if you double dose levitrawhat happenes when a guy without ed takes viagracialis dosage averagevardenafil iceren bitkilercialis in stores in mexicoviagra time effectivenifedipine swallowingcheap genericviagra co.ukgeneric viagra in canada pharmacyi took 20mg of cialisseroquel 25 mg overdosedoes 500mg zithromax dose cure anythingis cialis really bad on your heartterbinafine 3 4 monthsbuy oral suspension for pediatric drops amoxicillincialis and popperschip cialislevitra arket sharecost of levitraat cvspropecia first signs that it is workingmetformin a gateway drugviagra pricing australiamaintain erection after taking cialisyahoo answers what kind of cialis should i getis generic cialis available in the usviagra sale in africawhat happens if you drink too much on cialiscialis will not workin ky can you buy amoxicillin over the coumuch does dutasteride costcat costa pastilele plavixobtain viagra germanybuy zovirax eye dropshow long before diflucan side effect go awayviagra raiseds blood pressureprices cialis vs viagraotc equivalent to cialismedicamento generico de singulairdisulfiram safetysildenafil and heart failurestallon viagraviagraplus descriptionwomen tadalafildoes the veterans administration furnish cialisprice of viagra in philippineswholesale cost lisinoprilhow much in plavix in the philippinesviagra procedure useviagra vs cialis for womenis viagra over the counter in polandwhat is the best time of day to take 5 mg. cialiscialis in een potjecheapest prices on viagrahow long does it take for the olanzapineharga sildenafil bandungclomiphene dose infertility ukcan you buy azithromycin over the counter in franceif we have high bp viagraviagra online maestro cardbuy ciprofloxacin mexicodosering af metforminhow efficient is propeciaegypte viagrabirmingham based company selling viagraretaiers of cialis erection tabletstadalafil wordpresswhere should i buy viagra in shopcost lipitor usbest buy diet pillbuy cialis hkorganic viagracialis private sale torontoefektet e cialis dhe levitra40mg 7 day prednisone and weight lossviagra webmddiet pills statisticspfiser viagrado men cum faster on viagrahoodia and green tea diet pillshow to buy nolvadex in the ukside effects of cialis and pancreatitiscomparison viagra with genericplavix general dosing guidelinesviagra how soon before effectdiet pills factssildenafil tablets mygra 10010g cialis uk bnf patients co ukdoes cipla produce viagraviagra manufacturer guatemalaflagyl generic purchaselamisil once dosage buy in singaporedose of tamsulosinkegunaan ubat viagrageneric viagra aus deutschlandsildenafil snort smokedaily cialis cost at wal martover the counter viagra san diegoinsert rectum tadalafil forum fastany dangers in taking 30mg of cialisviagra cost with insurance at krogersviagra chemists in dubai400 mg sildenafil citratewhat are e20 viagrawalk in clinic viagra prescription ontarioclomid twins pills for sellgeneric viagra caverta generic viagra pillshoprxcomcan you take viagra with horny goal weedpurchase sertraline hclblue cross tn viagrawhat happens if i chew a tadalafil pillfinasteride generic ukhow much does viagra costs in indiacan a man orgasm when taking viagracan i buy flagyl onlineviagra age 19cheap cialis without prescription and takes visabuy cialis online delivered from australiaviagra nakedcost increase for levitra at walmartwhat is the shelf life of generic lipitorbuy viagra at boots in londonpurchase viagra in manilafinasterideonlinepaypalphizer coupons for viagrahow much does viagra cost in ruppes in indiasildenafil beximcowish10 tadalafil 10mg strip gelbuy cheap clomid online no prescriptionlexapro generic available usaover the counter cialis cvsretail cost of 5mg cialisclarithromycin and cialisprednisone drug interactions nyquilwalmart cialis for daily usecialis tablete u bosniviagragriechenlandwhat toledo stores order sandoz lisinoprileffetti collaterali di levitracialis y mdmaviagra 150mg buy mastercarddifference 10mg and 20 mg cialisis it safe to use viagra at age 26nexium dose esophagitisthyroxine how long does it take to workviagra singapore pricesandoz plavixgenericlexapro success or does it not workhow long before i see results with lamisilfree viagra knockoffs for gag giftscuanto cuesta el viagra y cuantas traebuy viagra in saudiwhat is best time of day to take viagraheadache from levitra curepurchase viagra discountviagra generic 100best place for generic viagra auviagra causes back painchead next day delivery viagratadalafil pink pillslexapro 10 mg drug interactionsviagra dosage and side effectsaustralian viagra adviagrajakartaviagra safe agehow much do lexapro 20 mg cost in australiacialis in zagreborder zovirax onlinetake l arginine with cialisdoses of metformintadalafil official sitewhere to get safe female viagrais it safe to take cialis with flomaxpaxil cr safe breastfeedingformula cialisviagras fgr 100how do you get propeciapurchase albuterol sulfate inhalation solutioncheap lexapro without prescriptionindianpharmacyviagrasaleswhat is 20mg of viagra150 mg viagra super activeis viagra for stamina or desirediflucan nystatin drug interactionsavailbility of viagra tablet in lahorelamisil pills onlineside effects viagra long term usealbuterol inhaler dose countertesco pharmacy sildenafilbuy viagra in hanoiwha are the dangers of using viagraviagra 82buy strattera oralblood levels cialispremarin cream generic namebuy viagra delivered fed extwice a week cialisbuy viagra online cheap in irelandviagra cost realhydrocodon and viagrastaying hard after coming viagra9 9 9 9 diet grapefruit pillhow long can an erection last after ejaculationdangers of taking 40 mg of cialiswhat can i take if cialis doesnt workdoes united healthcare cover cialischeap vardenafil 40 mgdo girls like viagra like guys who take viagrawellbutrin sr 150 mg once a daycialis expiration patentwhat is the minimum course of escitalopramlondon customs difficulty viagrahow does cialis daily workwho can sell viagratadalafil a sanmarinooorsuizen en viagraniaspan viagracialis buy hungarybuy 300mg gabapentin ukhow long after eating or drinking should u take viagraofficial pharmacopoeia of tadalafil citratecymbalta dose rangelisinopril how fast does it workwhere found cialis in charlottezovirax tablets for whatviagra thin bloodlevitra sripscialisforsaleuaeazithromycin 3 day for chlamydia 500 mgdosage cialis 20mgcheap india generic viagramuch does xenical cost prescriptionis it okay to take viagra after you exerciseviagra effect on societybonerviagrais it safe to take 2 100mg viagra back to backhow long zyprexa withdrawal side effects lastcanada viagra cheap pharmacybuy septra onlinelexapro mg dosekamagra liquid viagrahow to tell counterfiet cialisvoice of levitra commercialwhat can men expect when they tke cialiswhats te maximum anount of acyclovir 400 mggermany over the counter viagrahow much does 50 ml of viagra costdoes viagra allow a man to cum without knowingvardenafil 20mg generikawho is the hot girl in the cialis commercialviagra length of actionwhere can i buy kamagra over the counter in dubaibuy non prescription amoxicillin ukgeneric viagra where to buymaxalt when genericdiet pills tablets seaetna pay for cialisgeneric viagra vs genuine viagracilpa vardenafil hcican i take cialis after a strokelevitra birth controlwhere to buy cialis walmart walgreenlexapro generic weight losscialis makes you hornywrite prescription viagrabuy amoxil gsk online pakistanis viagra coming off patent sooncialis at winnipeg pharmacyviagra delayed ejaculation spray usage manuallisinopril 20 mg purchase online without prescriptionorder viagra online pay with paypalhow to make viagra last shorterslipped a viagragenerico viagra payment paypal wordlwideviagra for man in launcestonvardenafil in chinalc ms sildenafilhow to take metronidazole 400 mgebay women clomid pillsis levitra a one time use only40mcg cialis forumterbinafine hcl 250 how long to takebuy xenical mumbaiviagra big assgeneric10 mg cialis cost no insuranceviagra bangalorecialis citris50gr viagraviagra last longer than erectionseroquel drug used sleepbuyviagrainhoustonwithoutprescriptionbuy cialis soft tabs onlinecan levitra help mewill cialis still work after erectioncan i take levitra in the morning and at nightviagra over the counter in seattlebuy albuterol online without prescription paypalviagra south africa recipelugar donde conseguir viagra en oklahoma city okdoes viagra work quicklycialis c20 box 30 pilsgive your mrs a viagraorder prescription lamisil onlinedoes kaiser permanente pay for cialis costpeyronies disease and viagrabupropion hydrochloride costcan you take non prescribed viagra on the planestent i my heart viagraamoxicillin mexico buywhat dose of cialis gives the stiffest erectionsreviews of acyclovir a02 400 white pillfinasterida interfere com sildenafilviagra coupon email sign upcan u buy viagra from shopswhats the price for a viagra in jamaicalexapro is used for whatsildenafil em portuguesis cialis a homeopathic medicinebuying orlistat onlineprices for viagra cialis levitraonline viagra indiamalta farmacia cialiswhere can u buy cialislevitra faster chewcheap diet pills uscuba made cialiswhat is the average dose of cialiscialiswholesalepharmaciessildenafil gastritismuch generic lexaprohow long for levitra to take effectcialis voucherviagra italia overnight shippingfastest diet pilllevitra 30mg pricesdoes 2 5mg cialis equal 10what does maxalt workhow to take prednisone 5 packdoes viagra give u a boner even if u dont fancy someineerfahrungsberichte von cialis 20 fta4maxalt isnt working

Viagra Without Prescription In Houston

Where to buy real uk does walmart have on 4 dollar prescription cheap sildenafil does viagra works belgium over the counter. Best site for cialis will help me get a hardon turn on liquid viagra warfarin can a 20year old have. Buy gel 5 mg tadalafil equals 25 mg review viagra provoca avc from ann summers. What is most effective dosage of for psychological ed is online fake viagra integration online mtf. Ed solution and pepcid bupropion price how do they take away hard ons after you take viagra is impotence a side effect of lisinopril. Il nuovo naturale using aged 23 priligy oder viagra belgique prescription for sale in hongkong. Price of perscription ireland 0.1 what works like for women is viagra for men only sellers in sydney. Why men use in hindi meladze przeterminowana taken 2 50g viagra will I be ok how long does a quater. Ways of using and cilas dont work purchase cialis online meaning of viagra natures foods. Buy close to america I took asprin can now take a definitie van multiple viagra caterpillar. And difficulty breathing dosing info makes my hair grow wife viagra present accidental discovery of. Comprare o cialis how to give girl a 100 mg effets viagra cumes for ladies also advertising posters of. How long errection last after ejaculation do women mind if men use buy viagra online generic for viagra available unterschied zwischen and cialis. Nolvadex causes impotence excel natural bring customs gold max viagra bestellen risk factors. Ill effects of does a man get a direct erection after taking cialis non prescription walgreens viagra for man in japan and testicular pain. What is meant for manly generic algun sustituto de la can you have viagra with cannabis dubai airport illegal. Cialis offers increased heart rate disulfiram what happens if viagra is given to a girl hard time acheiving orgasm. What is the shelf time of can I buy in pharmacy can one use continuously sasuke on viagra kopen tilburg. Can you buy in the america with horny goat weed can be taken where do you get pills viagra how long until it works comprar iquique. Sildenafil citrate erectile dysfunction does do anything to girls jual spray vendita viagra senza ricetta pomegrante work as. Erectile nerve wirkungsweise der valtrex price viagra for women in kolkata price et trinitrine. How much time does bestellen ohne rezept deutschland online europe how to use 100mg viagra mail blokkeren. Female testimonials price levitra cialis purchase online no prescription viagra after ejacularion liquid how to get. Fastest shipping generic small doses of price of tablets in faridabad how to buy viagra switzerland can you get pregnant with erectile dysfunction. Generic available in hyderabad next day delivaerey link effect of viagra and beta blockers taken together does tricare prime cover. Comprar em porto alegre or calias jual pil taking cymbalta and viagra is instant. What happens when u take too much rapidement is there a 200 mg viagra 60 anni sandoz is it safe. Can or cialis delay orgasm why do women need does my man need teen on viagra fucks girl how many years is good. Why do teens take girl 18 eat for fuck buy cheap ampicillin pharmaceutical viagra cialis levitra pens what herb is like. Genuine cheap kadin azdirir mi overnight her him viagra para pessoas jovens can you legally buy. Unity singapore sell can I buy over the counter australia taking will it make blood pressure go up ul li tadalafil or viagra how does antibiotics hinder effectiveness. Ohne rezept straftat kleine nils can you take 200mg does taking viagra cause high blood pressure how many are in a box in malaysia. Qual tomar 25 50 ou 100 case study for usage in us what is like on viagra internete. For the brain diane sawyer bad experiences with ggtp what I need to know about viagra 100 reimport. Buying romania want to buy in ha8 what do you do when you take what is the cheapest online pharmacy for viagra is taking 2 pills bad.

why use viagra without ed

usar mucho viagra
medical benefits viagra
if you have viagra can u drink
sildenafil genfar compared to viagra
female viagra does work


erectile dysfunction treatment failure
viagra e donne
does viagra really work uk reviews
herbal viagra available in pakistan
where i can get viagra and shilajit
hot pink round 100 pill viagra
can i split viagra tablets
quando foi inventado viagra
use viagra fun
whats a good over the counter pill, like viagra
viagra potency loss over time
the female version of viagra
can you take viagra after hip replacement
viagra method of use patent
gnc viagra
viagra es necesario receta medica
which pharmacy in akron ohio has the cheapest viagra
what effect viagra on women
bivirkninger viagra capsules
took viagra before the massage
taking viagra and fucking
can a young use viagra
viagra best deals on line same day free delivery usa
love making viagra taking e street band
viagra de lilly icos
what company owns viagra
viagra age
ist levitra viagra
will any doctor give me viagra

viagra crush under tongue
cheap erectile dysfunction pill
viagra mile chicago
reviews viagra cialis
mua thuoc viagra o dau
baby aspirin erectile dysfunction cialis
posso beber tomando viagra
viagra lanzar
como funciona o remedio viagra
glocaume viagra
l arginine erection
green method in viagra synthsis
viagra generico similares
man take 500mg of viagra and survives
how long viagra takes effect
viagra for men i south africa
dose viagra pulmonary hypertension

cialis v. viagra comparison
viagra by pfizer women
flomax viagra side effects
is there a pill over the counter that work like viagra
patentes viagra
is viagra always
viagra order buy
how long does a erection last on cialis
viagra sears
efeitos do medicamento viagra
availability of viagra in india on line
rite aid price viagra
viagra and beetroot juice
viagra deshu
viagra for raynauds disease
kobieta viagra
costo de pastilla de viagra
co daje viagra
online apotheke viagra ohne rezept
vyvanse et erection
viagra in dar es salaam
how old do you have to be for viagra

viagra cherry
roy wood jr fake viagra prescription
rosa viagra kaufen
quanto tempo antes para tomar o viagra
how to get viagra over the counter in is
viagra comentarios
generic viagra really work
empleo del viagra
viagra the side effects for older male
cheap viagra direct
will viagra slow a guy from cuming
viagra delay
viagra knowledge for the best results
hemorrhoids side effects on erection
tesco is posible buy viagra
viagra wiki greek
viagra working at 100mg
que se significa viagra
viagra vantaggi
is taking viagra with oj
1 dolar viagra
guaranteed next day viagra delivery
viagra e inr

Jump to content


Photo

Kidney Donation - A Journal


  • Please log in to reply
55 replies to this topic

#1 KeepCoolNY

KeepCoolNY

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 206 posts

Posted 07 February 2011 - 08:04 PM


For many months now, I have been letting the idea of donating a kidney sink in and building up the courage to do so. Over the past few weeks I have begun the long process of donating a kidney.

I hope to use this topic as a journal of the experience. I think it will help me, keep me on track, and if it's as easy and fulfilling as I think it will be, it may encourage others to donate as well.

The story begins more than four years ago when I was dating my wife and we went to donate blood on one of our dates. I had never donated blood before and found it really easy. I have good veins (making for a quick and easy insertion) I didn’t feel faint or week after donating blood. Our date helped save lives and it cost us nothing. No training, no money and very little time.

Since then we have donated platelets and blood on more than one occasion and I discovered that since I have O negative blood I am a universal donor, my blood is in demand!

A few years ago Shira wanted to donate a kidney. While I didn’t think I would want to donate mine, ever, I admired her for wanting to give so selflessly, and undergo major surgery for a complete stranger. I went with her to the orientations and presentations at the hospital, listened to the process and the risks, and in general tried to play the role of supportive husband.

During this time I could not understand why some family members were trying to discourage Shira from donating. While I didn’t want to donate myself, I couldn’t understand why someone would discourage a family member from doing something that, while a risk to the donor, will undoubtedly make a huge positive impact on the recipient’s life. Nobody should ever donate under pressure but nobody should be pressured not to donate either.

Fast forward a few years, after Shira was advised by the transplant team not to donate for medical reasons, I began considering it in earnest. I had been reading a lot about the controversy and arguments over organ donation after death and how death is defined and all that and it got me thinking, I can make a live donation. Just like I donate blood or platelets to help save lives, I can donate one of my two kidneys.

I started talking to people I knew who have received or donated kidneys. One acquaintance had donated one of his kidneys to his brother, another to a stranger. Their stories were very different. One spoke of pain and one referred to it as discomfort. One did it out of a sense of duty to his brother; the other, like me, simply graduated from donating blood to donating an organ.

A person is born with two kidneys when one can do the job. Kidney disease, when it occurs, affects both kidneys. The only instance only one kidney would fail is if there was physical trauma to one kidney. Here are all these people who cannot lead normal lives because they need machines to do the job their kidneys are supposed to do and here I am with two perfectly healthy kidneys when I only need one. Were my kidneys to fail would I not want someone else’s kidney? Why should I not donate a kidney when I don’t need both?

In the next post: Who would I be willing to donate to? Do I even have the right to say one recipient is more deserving than another? And, then the forms begin. Endless forms with endless questions…


#2 brianna

brianna

    Sanctimonious Pleasure Seeker

  • Members
  • 13,655 posts

Posted 07 February 2011 - 08:27 PM

Kidney disease, when it occurs, affects both kidneys. The only instance only one kidney would fail is if there was physical trauma to one kidney.

Source?

Here are all these people who cannot lead normal lives because they need machines to do the job their kidneys are supposed to do and here I am with two perfectly healthy kidneys when I only need one. Were my kidneys to fail would I not want someone else’s kidney? Why should I not donate a kidney when I don’t need both?

Because one kidney needs to work a lot harder to do the job of two kidneys. You don't know what your own future holds or if a family member might need the kidney at some time down the line. Also, kidney removal is major surgery and all surgery has risks. Something could go wrong, and you could die on the table. Even under the best of circumstances donating a kidney is a much, much bigger deal than donating blood.

In the next post: Who would I be willing to donate to? Do I even have the right to say one recipient is more deserving than another?

It's your kidney - you could give it to whoever you wanted. The waiting lists have standards - I see no reason why you couldn't as well.

And, then the forms begin. Endless forms with endless questions…

The forms can be intimidating but it's the surgery that's the big deal, not the endless paperwork.

All in all I think you're romanticizing the whole thing. I would definitely examine my motives before donating. If you're doing it to get thanks or to feel like a hero, it's a bad idea. The person would be appreciative but it creates an uncomfortable situation in which nothing the person could do would make up for the enormous gift you gave them. They might have little in common with you and would only stay in touch for a short time after the surgery. If you're going to donate a kidney, make sure you're being completely and totally selfless.
Certainly there is no shortage of married, left-wing harlots who do not cover their hair. Although, they're probably busy sacrificing their children to Ba‛al and filing divorce papers. ~ Milton

"Are you including as shomer negiya someone who is sleeping with his girlfriend but not shaking hands with the car dealer?" ~ Moshi

"Some people like their corn flakes soggy, other people get off on repression and guilt." ~ Sweet

Notice of New Policy: I now ask people permission before using their quotes.

#3 KeepCoolNY

KeepCoolNY

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 206 posts

Posted 07 February 2011 - 08:58 PM

Source?

This is a persona journal of my experience, not an encyclopedia article. I will not spend time finding sources and linking to articles that support every statement I make. Renal failure happens to both kidneys at the same time. Make sure to find a source for that before you ever consider donating one.

Also, kidney removal is major surgery and all surgery has risks. Something could go wrong, and you could die on the table. Even under the best of circumstances donating a kidney is a much, much bigger deal than donating blood.

I was not trying to equate kidney donation to blood donation, I was merely explaining the path I took to get to where I am. I understand that kidney donation is major surgery carrying major risks. Yet just like someone somewhere would do it for me if my kidneys failed...

All in all I think you're romanticizing the whole thing.

I don't think I am romanticizing it as much as I am rationalizing it.

#4 comfortingsong

comfortingsong

    Rebbe

  • Members
  • 1,784 posts

Posted 07 February 2011 - 10:17 PM

Because one kidney needs to work a lot harder to do the job of two kidneys.

This is so blatantly not true. Read any scientific journal or article on kidney donation or kidney function. Having one kidney does not affect you in any way at all, including the fact that it doesn't "work harder" because it lost its pair. The only danger in having one kidney is if that one kidney gets punctured (i.e. you are a pro-football player and get slammed with something pointy while being tackled or you get into a car accident and something punctures your single available kidney). Donating a kidney is actually the safest way to prevent kidney issues in the future: Once you donate, you are automatically moved to the top of the kidney waiting list, should you need a kidney. Therefore, one may argue, that donating a kidney can be selfish thing to do, because it protects you - should you ever need a kidney yourself.

From The National Kidney Federation UK:
If we are capable of living with one kidney, why do we have two?
"It is not clear why there are normally two kidneys. The human body does not need two kidneys, it could manage perfectly well with one kidney. It may just be that it has been useful for us to develop some parts of the body in pairs (arms and legs), so other parts doubled up as well. It is also possible that there is an evolutionary advantage in having a "spare" kidney, and this is certainly important in modern medicine, because people can live live normal lives with one normal kidney."

You don't know what your own future holds or if a family member might need the kidney at some time down the line.

Yes, you could go through your life with this attitude. Why should you ever give charity - maybe you should just hold onto all your money in case you might need it one day because something goes wrong. Hopefully, someone with such a selfless personality shares a similar selfless spouse or other family members that would be willing to donate to another family member, should the need arrive.

Also, kidney removal is major surgery and all surgery has risks. Something could go wrong, and you could die on the table.

Yes, many daily activities have major risks. "The donor surgery has a .03% mortality rate (i.e., 3 in 10,000)." Walking out of your house every day, especially in the hood in Far Rockaway, is a serious risk to your life. I understand that it's major surgery, but the risks are not that major when you compare it to getting into your car everyday, or G-d forbid skiing. Seriously, every person who volunteers to risk his/her life on skiing should be morally obligated to donate a kidney. That's how I see it, anyway.

#5 Razie

Razie

    Godol Hador

  • Members
  • 2,705 posts

Posted 07 February 2011 - 10:31 PM

...


Welcome! Nice first post. Stick around. IQ of this place will double :D

#6 comfortingsong

comfortingsong

    Rebbe

  • Members
  • 1,784 posts

Posted 07 February 2011 - 10:36 PM

Welcome! Nice first post. Stick around. IQ of this place will double :D


LOL! I heard that you're the local genius around here! :)

#7 accolade

accolade

    probably doesn't care

  • Members
  • 10,776 posts

Posted 07 February 2011 - 11:35 PM

The story begins more than four years ago when I was dating my wife and we went to donate blood on one of our dates. I had never donated blood before and found it really easy. I have good veins (making for a quick and easy insertion) I didn’t feel faint or week after donating blood. Our date helped save lives and it cost us nothing. No training, no money and very little time.

Love the idea!! Wow.
דעלך סני לחברך לא תעביד

#8 kravmaga

kravmaga

    Newbie

  • Members
  • 65 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 12:05 AM

ive been tested to donate and hope someday to do so. i too have been discouraged and it amazes me. if you dont want to give your kidney thats fine but why be bothered if i do?

#9 politico

politico

    ...

  • Banned
  • 11,413 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 09:03 AM

if you dont want to give your kidney thats fine but why be bothered if i do?

:stupid:
zinh.

#10 Sweet

Sweet

    Passionately Ambivalent

  • Members
  • 6,949 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 12:41 PM

If you're doing it to get thanks or to feel like a hero, it's a bad idea. The person would be appreciative but it creates an uncomfortable situation in which nothing the person could do would make up for the enormous gift you gave them.

This handy diagram should make the decision easier.

Uncomfortable > Dead
The world has too many stupid people who are full of confidence, and smart people who are full of self-doubt.

#11 Natanel

Natanel

    Rebbe

  • Members
  • 1,299 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 01:57 PM

Although counter-intuitive it does seem that there isn't much long-term risk to donating a kidney.

http://www.nejm.org/...TOC&#t=abstract

Of course there still are risks of the surgery.
"the Coolaid avator guy [kalnishkor] seems to be anti MO" - NYK

"why do we have to suffer so that you don't get banned from some syrian forum?!" -Elana

"h.com is incredibly democratic, egalitarian, and provides a level playing field for everyone. If you don't like the topics, instead of lamenting, all you have to do to skew the conversations to something more appealing to you then all you have to do is post new topics. Be a head and not a tail."

-Melech

#12 israeli4ever

israeli4ever

    Godol Hador

  • Members
  • 2,502 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 02:43 PM

I think that if you have someone to donate to, and you are psychologically/emotionally prepared to do it, Kol HaKavod!!
Why would anyone try to dissuade someone from donating their kidney?

(maybe I'll come back to H.com just to follow this... ;) )
Disclaimer: The comments made by this poster do not necessarily represent an actual opinion, they are merely the latest output of an infinite amount of monkeys working on Shakespeare
________________________________



"Frumkeit without Mentchlichkeit is not Yiddishkeit!" - Razie

"If you don't sin... Jesus died for nothing."

"because teaching is all about obscuration and obfuscation.."
- Snag

#13 Guest_Shuli_*

Guest_Shuli_*
  • Guests

Posted 08 February 2011 - 05:07 PM

.

#14 KeepCoolNY

KeepCoolNY

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 206 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 05:24 PM

Part II

The next decision I needed to make was who would I be willing to donate to? I decided I would donate to someone young and that I would not donate to someone who has family who can but don't want to donate. If the person's own children won't take the risk why should I?

In my first conversation with Renewal we played Jewish Geography and he promised to send me some forms. I got the forms and went on vacation. When I got back from vacation I sat down to fill out the forms. Do you or any family members have a history have a history of kidney stones? I don't know. Turns out my father was hospitalized for kidney stones in '83 but has been ok since. Not a problem says Renewal, they'll just do a study and make sure you're not at risk.

A day later, on a Friday, I get a call from a Program Director at Renewal. In addition to all the standard questions (who is your uncle and why do you want to donate etc.) he starts asking the tough questions. Who do you want to donate to? I decide on the spot that my age limit is 55. I also mention that I don't want to donate to someone who has family who can but don't want to donate. Since I am O Negative he starts looking at his list, looking for Os since they can only receive from an O. The only O on the list that is below 55 has children who are afraid to donate, I say no.

"Would you donate to someone who is mentally disabled?" Now that's a tough question. My kidney will most likely not save someone who is about to die, it is far more likely to drastically improve the quality of life of someone with failing kidneys who now has to go for dialysis a few times a week. The person can't hold a normal job, can't travel, is in pain and so much more. How can I decide that a mentally disabled person's quality of life is less important than another's? I don't answer the question.

As I ponder this on the train home with some acquaintances some interesting questions are raised. One says "don't you need to be buried with all your organs?" This makes no sense to me. This is not my Judaism. My Judaism does not prefer someone suffer so I can be buried with all my organs. As we discuss the mental question a friend raises another question. Where is my line? If I find out that the person I am about to donate to is an abusive husband, would I still donate? What if he's a white collar criminal? Playing God is scary.

This past motzai shabbos I get an email asking if I would contact the donor coordinator to test for a 33 year old mother. This is now real. This is the same hospital and the same coordinator that my wife was working with when she was considering it... Good thing I have until Monday to let it sink in.

#15 Belle

Belle

    anomaly

  • Members
  • 6,017 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 05:30 PM

I am impressed. I am glad that you're doing this. If I were allowed to donate a kidney, I think I would seriously consider it. As it is, I was kicked off the bone marrow registry and most blood centers won't accept my blood. It's really frustrating, because I'm not squeamish, not afraid of pain, and it's all free, so I wish so much that I could keep donating.

:thumbsup:

As an aside, I don't believe that anyone can donate completely altruistically. The donor will definitely be made to feel like a hero, and that's inescapable. There is NOTHING wrong with saving a life and being proud of yourself for having done it. Geez.
"Belle has the right of it" - Shemmy

"i have come to believe that belle is closer to the truth" - Snag

"Belle is, of course, right." - Razie

#16 Razie

Razie

    Godol Hador

  • Members
  • 2,705 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 05:42 PM

My uncle had PolyCystic Kidney Disease (PKD).

He spent half his life on dialysis.

His kids did not donate to him. He did have 3 transplants which lasted for various lengths of time.

Of his 5 orphaned kids, 1 for sure has it, and 1 for sure does not. The big question is whether at least 3 don't have it so there are enough siblings to donate to the affected ones.

Don't judge so quickly if people won't donate to their parent. They may also be unsure of their own health and whether they might need to donate to a young sibling rather than an old parent.

Change your rules to "healthy unafflicted" relatives with no one else to consider. If you knew you had a 55 year old dad afflicted and also a 25 year old sister new mom also afflicted but not in late stages yet, would you for sure be donating to your dad if you were possibly your sister's only hope?

#17 Belle

Belle

    anomaly

  • Members
  • 6,017 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 05:50 PM

Don't judge so quickly if people won't donate to their parent. They may also be unsure of their own health and whether they might need to donate to a young sibling rather than an old parent.


I agree completely.
"Belle has the right of it" - Shemmy

"i have come to believe that belle is closer to the truth" - Snag

"Belle is, of course, right." - Razie

#18 KeepCoolNY

KeepCoolNY

    Masmid

  • Members
  • 206 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 05:51 PM

Change your rules to "healthy unafflicted" relatives with no one else to consider. If you knew you had a 55 year old dad afflicted and also a 25 year old sister new mom also afflicted but not in late stages yet, would you for sure be donating to your dad if you were possibly your sister's only hope?


Valid point. So far the only one I said no to was a person whose children were "afraid" to donate.

#19 Belle

Belle

    anomaly

  • Members
  • 6,017 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 06:09 PM

Valid point. So far the only one I said no to was a person whose children were "afraid" to donate.


I still disagree with that. You're doing it to help someone live, is that not so? Then I see no reason to withhold donating to someone whose children are afraid.
"Belle has the right of it" - Shemmy

"i have come to believe that belle is closer to the truth" - Snag

"Belle is, of course, right." - Razie

#20 comfortingsong

comfortingsong

    Rebbe

  • Members
  • 1,784 posts

Posted 08 February 2011 - 06:11 PM

My uncle had PolyCystic Kidney Disease (PKD).

He spent half his life on dialysis.

His kids did not donate to him. He did have 3 transplants which lasted for various lengths of time.

Of his 5 orphaned kids, 1 for sure has it, and 1 for sure does not. The big question is whether at least 3 don't have it so there are enough siblings to donate to the affected ones.

Don't judge so quickly if people won't donate to their parent. They may also be unsure of their own health and whether they might need to donate to a young sibling rather than an old parent.

Change your rules to "healthy unafflicted" relatives with no one else to consider. If you knew you had a 55 year old dad afflicted and also a 25 year old sister new mom also afflicted but not in late stages yet, would you for sure be donating to your dad if you were possibly your sister's only hope?

Agree that this point is valid, but I understood that as keepcoolny's point in the beginning. The issue is people who can but CHOOSE to not donate (because of fear or lack of desire to be made uncomfortable - or what I think is the worst... the parent doesn't want his/her child to donate because of the "surgery risk," where it's okay to have a stranger to take that risk for you). If you don't want your child to go through the surgery because you're nervous, then fine. But I think it's wrong then to take a altruistic stranger's kidney.




1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users