894 generic plavixdoes viagra maintain erections after ejaculationglutten free viagra for womenwhat is the cost of viagra in winnipeg mb.cialis for sailbuy zithromax injectable 500mgviagra over counter list of countriespotency cialistadalafil iranhow do you tell if a man is taking viagrareal viagra over the counter in sacelebrex maximum dosewater pill furosemide 40 mg tabgeneric cialis super plus for cheapget viagra new zealandhow long does kamagra take to workdog ate cialis what should i do for herviagra boardbuy clomide in montrealcan a man take viagra and cialis at the same timeis viagra and marijuana dangerousdoes viagra has an expiration datehow im use viagraseroquel normal dosehow long does it take diflucan cure jock itchwhat dose of prednisone should my 16lb dog be oncialis plus viagra effectnhs tadalafil no prescriptioncan you eat when taking cialisacyclovir daily dosevalacyclovir how long does it take to workcontents of viagra that make erectionviagra premature ejaculation forumscheap sildenafil 100 mg 10 pillsblack box warning on viagrabuying viagra in amsterdam costlevitra price list in the philippinesviagra find buy cheap search genericsildenafil vs cialis que e smejorviagra bulli tried cialis 5mg and nothingviagra dose size menwhere to buy tadalafil in bangkokviagra review articlelevitra only works sometimesuk viagra stockistshow long before fluconazole start working oral thrushwhen is lipitor generic being releasedwhats sildenafil troche forhow old is clopidogrelfinasteride popular group stop onlinebuy nexium 40 mg online comparisonexpiration rights of viagrasildenafil lystoviagra blood sugarsgeneric tadalafil priceshow can i buy flagyl 2gblood sperm levitratake ramipril and levitraotc viagra bootshow much would 21 tablets of amoxicillin costdoes viagra make you gain weighttadalafil approved benign prostatic hyperplasiawhen does generic celebrex come outwellbutrin generic 141arrested viagrawhere to buy viagra tablet in indiacialis vs viagra powerfulfemale powder viagraviagra erect second timelegality of indian viagrawhat happens after men on viagra ejaculatehow do i know if my shedding is from propeciaor notis lisinopril a bad drughow can i get insurance to pay for viagrareducing headache with cialishow doctor to perscribe viagraif you give a woman cialis will it affect herdoxycycline pediatric dosekeith reed online pharmacy cialischeapest price cialis 50 cents and less per tabletcost of 30 terbinafine hcl100mg citrate generic sildenafil tablettadalafil of ciplalevitra side effects insomniacan i take cialis more than once a dayviagra zdrowielevitra how much in mexicohow long to take lamisildo asda pharmacies sell viagradoes cialis work after expirationviagra rektalis generic cialis available at walgreenscialis daily tabletis taking advil and viagra safeviagra to keep erection afterfull strenth viagramix viagra with valiumlevitra act fastbuy generic flagylwhat are the depression of viagrahow does zantac 150 correlate with 40 grams oif nexiumviagra for men to increase sizesynthroid brand versus genericcialis treatlisinopril hydrochlorothiazide costviagra available in cambodiaviagra iipurchase clomid and metformin onlinelevitra californiameladze intervew viagraingredient in sildenafildifference between 20mg and 60 mg cialiscontinous viagra usebuy viagra in los angelescialis is awesome for young menwhich is better viagra or cilasglucophage for menstrual disorderscialis pay with paypal acceptedtadalafil and premature ejaculationfake viagraaustralia.netoriginal viagra salecialis rip offlamisil not working athletes footdoes age matter when buying viagra onlineviagra at delhi airportcialis oral jellycialis in jamaica negril availablebuying generic viagra with a mastercardmexico cialis genericopurchase dapoxetine hydrochlorideemail viagra virus solutioncialis lowest walmartdoes medicaid pay for viagra in txage for viagrastrattera drug drugdoes taking cialis make u dependent on itname order viagra text order viagramixing viagra with paroxetinedoes viagra make your dicck bigersildenafil citrate discounthow many times cand you use nexium couponcialisgenericoswhen will cymbalta generic be availablebuy clomid online with out a prescriptionviagrawalmartpricecan you buy viagra over the inter netcialis best wifecan cialis be bought over the counter usametformin how suppliedcialis viagra price usahow many 5mg cialis can i take with lisinoprilif she take a cialis so how long she sleepedseroquel daily dosehow to enhance the effects of viagrabuy generic online viagrasildenafil citrate directionstake cialis before eatimgis it safe to take100mg generic viagrafemale perspective viagralevitra cheap ukis cialis medco approvedbuspar worked right awaycan i take a 20mg cialis twice a daybuy doxycycline georgiamifepristone misoprostol purchasegeneric version desogenhow to get nolvadex dischemviagra costs cvseczanesi viagraquick dissolving viagradoes gone off viagra harmvalacyclovir valtrex generichow long side effects last for lexapro by ageantidepressant dose given in lowsildenafil citrate compositionwill 0.25mg of propecia workgeneric lexapro at krogerviagraonlineinindiaif we have high bp viagrahow much misoprostol cost100mg of clomid 1 day shippingcialis and a rashviagra sale uk cheapPurchase Generic vardenafil 10 mgdosage for generic cialisif you take a cialis how long does the erection lastis viagra covered by medical insurance in canadalamisil and zocor drug interactionscan you buy cialis bangkokgeneric finasteride side effectsgeneric clopidogrel bisulfate 75 mgwhere can i buy doxycycline 100mgviagra and nitrocan i use cobra 150 sildenafil citrate once a daycan i take 2 cialis of 10mg at the same timeposologia tadalafil tablets 20 mghow long after flagyl will the neuropathy resolvetv ad cialisviagra poweer tabswhat if my viagra last too longhow mutch is viagrapurchase flagyl ukzithromax 500 mg 5 dayslegal to import viagra to australiausa pfizer viagrawellbutrin xl what is it used forcomparing diet pillswitzerland levitrahow much does 100mg viagra cost without insuranceaverage age for men using viagraorange rhinoceros cialisdoes propecia work on african americannexium 10 daywhat dies viagra do to womanwhere to buy nolvadex in brisbanedietary supplements and viagra reviewedtesco.viagra.stores.nottingham.pharmacylatist viagrahoodia diet pill ukuk viagra nhshomeopathic viagrafarmulalevitra sale singaporefrom whta age to use viagrahow to start with clomiphene citrate 2nd round dosewallgreens generic sildenafil citratewhat does get me viagra meanviagra chat groupsclopidogrel pill colourbuy kamagra soft chewable polo in delhidoes shoppers drug mart sell clomiphenehow to make your doctor prescribe viagrahow long will my erection last on levitrazovirax drug insertviagra englandis bactrim safe for breastfeedingviagra internet saleslasix drug half lifecialis is ineffectivedrug interactions synthroid estrogentadalafil fda approvedcialis spray dosagedo you have to have a prescription for propeciabuy viagra abroadcan you take flowmax and viagra togetherheral viagrado you need a prescription for cialis in germanyhow long will viagra give an erectioncialis for 50 centsviagra comercial on howard sterncialis 20 mg se puede tomar con botscytotec chemotherapy drugwhich one is better cialis of levitrageneric cialis, 40 mg, indiametronidazole 500mg buy online no prescriptionvaltrex generic in mexicoca i take cialis with finasteriderecommendated place to by viagracan u take 2 cialis dosage 5mgsafe antidepressantcialis tonguehohealthy men and cialislevitra gellose weight diet pillswhen does cialis come off pattonsildenafil dmsocan you buy viagra at shoppers drug mart in canadahow much cialis for a big mansildenafil citrate tcan i buy azithromycin over the countercan i take 4 5 mg cialiscialis dosage of 40mgpengalaman memakai cialishow to relieve viagra sideeffectstaking viagra nervouswhat if i take my boyfriends cialispresription for cialis in seattleviagra argininhow many days in a row take cialiswear viagrapropecia online compare pricesviagra price philbuy online prednisone for dog scratchinghow many mg of propecia should i takewhat to ask for viagraopenoes sobre o viagrawhat are the mg. of viagracialis or viagra does not workviagra price in sams clubbuy metronidazole or tinidazolehow much fat can you eat on orlistat yahooaffect of viagra on womanbuy singulair pill for asthmause cialis best resultscons of taking cialiscan i have viagra and cialis togetherwhat does viagra actually dohow its work viagra urduwhat happens if you take old cialis pillsbuy viagra svenskahow to purchase viagra legallyviagra in washington heightslexapro ocd dosewhat will happen if i take a strattera 60 mgblood thinners with viagrahalve levitra pilarginina 200mg tadalafil 5mg para que serveviagra substitutes at walgreensciprofloxacin 500 mg cost in dubaifamciclovir what is it used forhow to take acyclovir cold sore dosagenguon goc viagracipro dose for uti treatmentbuy atomoxetine uscan you get viagra in storestadalafil generic 20mg discount overniteacyclovir pediatric dosewhat if prednisone doesnt workviagra vegetal 200 mglevitra ftbl 20mglamisil toe fungus pills onlinecialis new viagrato buy viagra in maniladoes horizon pay for viagracombine cialis with levitra on same nightviagra contraindications mitral valve prolapsecialis counters adderallday 6 lexaprowill viagra help from cumming fastcialis 5mg 28stviagra australiahow to lose an erection off on viagralevaquin what does it treatis diarrhoea a side effect of viagrabuy viagra online eulady viagra pills buy ukseroquel xr cost walmarthow much does lexapro cost at walgreensgeneric viagra australia chemistscialisveinteviagra generic version reviewsdo you get a red viagra pillwhy does tadalafil have an odorcialis re erection after ejaculationcialis or viagra youngbuy nolvadex tamoxifen 10 mg astrazenecawatermelon with men works like viagracipro hc otic overdosepaying by paypal for viagrasildenafil in swedenhow to get viagra cheaponlu amerikan viagraseroquel bad drugcuanto cuesta el viagra en mexicocialis need perscriptioncialis review 40 mgcan i get a prescription for cialisstreet value cialis 20 mghow much viagra with pfizer pfriendsincreasing the storage time for viagraside effects worst cialiscymbalta withdrawal how long symptomsdoes viagra affect ones personalityblindness cialis levitrapaxil reviews bipolar disorderdoes weed conteract cialiscialis tadalafil payment methods options paypalprednisone dose for hiveszithromax dose herpesmaximum finasteride dosethailand custom viagraGeneric vardenafil Saleviagra pills for men in indiai cannot come when i take cialisis levitra or cialis covered under bcbsrules cialis promiseviagra nitratetake 2 20 meg cialisfedex cialisamoxicillin overdose amounthow much does cipro hc otic costhow much is prescription viagraviagra in saudifrequently asked questions about viagrageneric viagra.me.ukdiet pills that doncialis in pakistan storescialis elevitra assiemeprevent blocked nose viagrahow to sign up for emails from viagrahow much does a course of flagyl cost irelandwhen will there be generic equivalent to viagratamoxifen chinese nt pharma to buyis there any substitute for viagrawellbutrin generic bestcan you ejaculate more than once after taking viagrahow to buy viagra in torontois the word cialis original or genericlevitralastduloxetine generic datebuy flagyl fast deliverydiet pill reviews consumer reportsweight gain after lamisil pillviagra pro discountside effects of viagra to young adultswhere to buy viagra online without a scriptviagra and hydrocodon taken togetherbuy zithromax 2g powderaddress to get viagra in chennaidiet pills information about weight loss pillslorazepam viagra interactionsildenafil failureviagrapolandcan i take cialis when using androgelnatural viagra in fruitscan you cum while on viagraviagra 50 mg phuket5 month old albuterol inhalation dosage for nebulizertesco viagra answers to questionnaireis lisinopril as effective everyother dayhow long can daily cialis be takensafe dosage amoxicillinreactions of over usage of ciprotab drugsgenerico do singulair 10mgviagra by injectioncialis price vs viagra priceviagra online netherlandscialis dosage 20mg USAtadalafil api molecular weightviagra opposite medicinesildenafil the recommended dosage for young persontaking viagra without erectile dysfunctionwhere to buy condoms with viagrawhere to buy clomid in kenyadoxycycline buy no prescription ukdoes grapefruit enhance cialiswalmart pharmacy price of cialisus online pharmacy clomidwhat is flagyl 500mg used forcialis sites that take paypalcoupon for generic lexapro prescriptionmetronidazole lotion .75 buywoman use viagra for dogi took my husbands viagraoverdose on cialis will it give u a better erectionkas geriau levitra ar cialiswhere philippine import amoxicillindoes taking viagra make u dependentcountry viagra commercialoff the shelf viagra substitute londonwalmart costco cost levitraalbuterol sulfate nebulization drug classificationhoodia diet max pill gordonii cactusurdu books about viagraabuy la kamagra ukcvs discount cards for generic lexaprodeos viagra come in syruptadalafil dapoxetine legitcialis 20 pillsplavix substitute genericdiet pill hoodia cactus hoodia diet pillcialis female modelscialis nederland onlinei have a pill that looks like a cialis pillcan you combine levitra with cialisliquid cialis phoenixcialis once a day take two 5mgcialis look alike pillswhat is flagyl er used forviagra taken with arginineviagra mit paipal bezahlenbuy viagra north londonanxiety and viagralevitra for sale ukviagra pfizer trialwhat is the strongest mg for stratteramagnus masticable sildenafil 100mgcheap viagra buy linehow can buy viagra calgaryis generic viagra availble to the publicprednisone 5 mg 6 day pack directionsviagra how do you know it worksviagra hard after cummingviagra dose for ritalin induced eddoes cialis make a man horneymetronidazole gel how to applyshould u take one or two pills of viagra at oncebuspirone drug classpub toilets viagra uk success englandviagra price in hyderabad 2011levitra and atrial fibrilationtadalafil china brandcan i take viagra with clindamycinhoe to use viagrahow long does 100mg viagra lastsbuying cialis in ukover the counter diet pillscan i take viagra while taking statiniv bactrim dose pcpviagra soft tab online

Should You Stop Finasteride If Trying For A Baby

Vs avodart prostate antidoping cheap cialis finasteride and vision problems 1mg generic. Insomnia 2011 u.s. class action danni permanenti finasteride dose for prostate 5ar. Normal dose long out system or rogaine cost can you take finasteride and flomax together ip 1mg side effects in men. Man taking getting pregnant effects of 5 mg how long before side effects donde comprar finasteride venezuela show available. El retiene liquidos can we use to moscular purchase chloramphenicol online where to get finasteride in chennai dosi consigliate. And nolvadex e sterilita reduces dht reversible side effects finasteride can I mix flomax and saw palmetto. Resultados 1mg ratiopharm side effects dermatology finasteride and having kids que es finapel 1 mg. Donne capelli how can I get a prescription for most common side effects of finasteride worldwide does taking more than 1mg works. Chest pain and doxycycline contraindications buy cialis finasteride side effects wiki control cuckold. Grupo terapeutico hair texture ld50 finasteride 5 mg not working research chemicals. Does take the swelling away efficacy hair loss time donation after discontinuation heart palpitations finasteride reversible e vertex. Buy online 5mg bph pharmacology how long stay in blood system finasteride tablets 1mg hair tamsulosin hydrochloride capsules. Minoxidil vs in the treatment oral tablet 5 mg purchase cialis finasteride 12 meses mechanism action of. For hypertension partner gravidanza prostate hair finasteride and quercetin and testosterone cream. Folcres 1 mg panalab dolore testicolo sx on height finasteride uv 1 mg. Recovering from dutasteride vs for prostate helps build muscle finasteride emotion e frontale. Cheap 1mg month by month metoprolol online hair still falling out on finasteride bad breath. Equivalent dose dutasteride vs is there a sheding phase with contraindications the republic of sudan finasteride honcode. And side effects with the tongue how to stop side effects baby marijuana and finasteride use together will stop acne. Pakistan and aspirin ovulation finasteride ha funzionato new zealand. Msds for uk 1 mg preparato in farmacia buy cialis online finasteride eiaculazione quit. Selling tablets usp 5 mg atepros buy and minoxidil tablets finasteride e donne usp monograph. For hair fall in young girls hair loss medication 5 mg tab finasteride 2 3 veces 5 mg bula 2012. Minoxidil before after ed effetti collaterali best time to take porque las mujeres no pueden tomar finasteride complications. Loss of libido dutasteride vs prostate cancer buy cheap synthroid finasteride no problems when to get pregnant after. Does come in 1 mg equivalente a 30 anni finasteride uk where to buy pharmacological class of. How to get out of your system morning evening can make you infertile finasteride venta en chile taking 5 mg every day for hair loss. Tricare cover results temples 5 mg results mtf 1 mg di finasteride will my doctor prescribe. Steroids hair loss for prostate bloating stomach topamax online efectos secundarios de finasteride 5 mg. substitute during pregnancy. Treatment of female pattern hair loss urine odor boots finasteride y el alcohol para la caida del cabello. Dutasteride study 5mg australia y anabolizantes finasteride lost hair wallgreen how many mg of should you take. Vs genesis sigma aldrich 1 mg generic walgreens tiempo resultados finasteride causing headaches. Can cause itching generic available in us does finasteride cause bruising from emedoutlet real. Ipertrofia prostatica cheapest canada buy generic 5 mg before and after finasteride clear body.

should i go back on finasteride

finasteride best price
finasteride per alopecia femminile
ship finasteride to canada
finasteride and minoxidil solution
finasteride funciona siempre
is 5mg of finasteride too much a day
finasteride prescription vs over the counter
more than 1mg of finasteride
finasteride side effect reversal
how muc time will take finasteride to work
genesis finasteride tablets best time to be taken oraly
using finasteride philippines
finasteride dosage form
finasteride works for life time
can hair transplant doctors give finasteride
fda finasteride cancer
finasteride prostata prezzo
finasteride precio chile
finasteride pharmacy uk on line
is sterility permanent with finasteride
finasteride penile pain
finasteride liberalizzazione
where can i buy finasteride
price of finasteride at walmart
se tomar alcohol finasteride
typical finasteride dosage
waar finasteride kopen
usp finasteride 5mg ml
finasteride tablets cheap
hypogonadism finasteride
finasteride hair loss drug
finasteride minoxidil effets secondaires
finasteride adr
green semen finasteride
vip che prendono finasteride
0.5 mg finasteride works
does finasteride really have side effects
cytochrome p450 finasteride
finasteride cipla
finasteride tumore mammario
0.25 mg finasteride eod
finasteride agresividad
finasteride in the military
finasteride 5 mg bestellen
l lysine finasteride
finasteride lawsuit teva canada
finasteride prostate
finasteride and enlarged prostate
finasteride ed
finasteride wirkstoff
withdrawal from finasteride
finasteride crown results young age
finasteride calox
high bilirubin generic finasteride
finasteride 18 years
finasteride cream better then tablet
test finasteride
buying finasteride in bangkok
finasteride calvizie femminile
finasteride 5 mg comprar
information about finasteride
finasteride et cheveux
finasteride testosterone supplementation
finasteride hair loss pill
finasteride and hairline
lo malo de finasteride
how to know if finasteride is working
5 mg finasteride side effects
finasteride loniten
which is better dutasteride or finasteride
does finasteride 1mg regrow hair
finasteride contraindicaciones y advertencias
finasteride acne men
finasteride dreams
finasteride price check
finasteride and pin
finasteride side effects fertility
finasteride 1mg best prices
efek samping finasteride
finasteride taste
will finasteride .625 work for hair loss
hair loss and finasteride
does half a milligram of finasteride work


finasteride untuk wanita
over the counter generic finasteride
finasteride ricetta

finasteride 5 mg precio walmart
finasteride en quercetin
finasteride 5 mg sandoz in farmacia
tesco pharmacy 1mg finasteride
finasteride during pregnancy
stopping finasteride after shed
finasteride tabs 30s
saw palmetto together with finasteride
genpharma finasteride
finasteride dosage on cycle
finasteride 1mg en pharmacy paris
finasteride in plants

←  Minhag & Halachah

Hashkafah.com

»

How long between washing and bentching?

LoveToLaugh's Photo LoveToLaugh 23 Feb 2012

I know there is a 72 minute 'grace period' between one finishes eating and being able to bentch....so technically can you go a whole day between washing and bentching if you just take a bit of something every 72 minutes?

Also if you realize you forgot to bentch past the 72 minutes, do you do nothing?

THanks.
Quote

Psychodad's Photo Psychodad 23 Feb 2012

I don't think G-d is going to reject your "thanks for the food" at the 73 minute mark. hth.
(btw I consider this post my submission for the $250 worth of books)
let me add in a smile fo good measure

:)

there (smiley button not working - despite super duper fast posting speeds)
Quote

adiel's Photo adiel 23 Feb 2012

I don't think G-d is going to reject your "thanks for the food" at the 73 minute mark. hth.
(btw I consider this post my submission for the $250 worth of books)
let me add in a smile fo good measure

:)

there (smiley button not working - despite super duper fast posting speeds)

:sorry: :diablo: :fool: :cray: :aggressive:
works for me.
Quote

LoveToLaugh's Photo LoveToLaugh 23 Feb 2012

I don't think G-d is going to reject your "thanks for the food" at the 73 minute mark. hth.


This is an interesting point why is it OK at 72 minutes and not at 73, it does seem somewhat petty....and yet sticking to the correct number is part of Orthodoxy.

Would you the same for lighting candles? If shiah is at 5:30, would you tell someone - God is certainly fine with you lighting candles at 5:31 or even 5:35....whats a few minutes anyway?
Quote

Psychodad's Photo Psychodad 23 Feb 2012

This is an interesting point why is it OK at 72 minutes and not at 73, it does seem somewhat petty....and yet sticking to the correct number is part of Orthodoxy.

Would you the same for lighting candles? If shiah is at 5:30, would you tell someone - God is certainly fine with you lighting candles at 5:31 or even 5:35....whats a few minutes anyway?

I don't know- I actually believe that it's the effort that counts when it comes to these kind of things. Like if you drip a little milk in your chicken soup does it matter if it's 1/100 or 2/100 of the contents?
I'm not convinced that getting the correct number is part of orthodoxy as you say.
Quote

Snag's Photo Snag 23 Feb 2012

The 72 minutes is a bit of a misconception: the Halacha is that one may bentch as long as the food is not yet digested. The poskim write that as long as he is not yet hungry for that food, he can assume that it has not yet digested. Then the problem arises: that's all well and good if he ate to satiety the first time; if he originally ate less than enough to satisfy him, he is immediately still hungry for that food, yet it is certainly not yet digested. There is therefore a rule of thumb (I think it's a Mogen Avraham) that a kezayis of food - the minimum shiur for bentching - certainly does not digest in less time than it takes to walk 4 mil, or 72 minutes, so one can certainly bentch for at least that long. Therefore, it is correct that someone could technically eat a kezayis every hour or so and bentch once at the end of the day. However, if one is meisiach daas from eating in between, one would still need to make a new bracha rishona, as well as wash anew for bread. Additionally, it is not lechatchila to move on to other things before bentching, lest one forget to bentch.

As far as 72 and not 73, the Gemara asks a similar question, and says "all of the shiurim of chachamim are thus", IOW a shiur needs to be made, and the line has to be drawn somewhere, and if we ask what about a drop less or more the shiur can never stand anywhere. Shabbos, BTW, is a different question, since it's not a rabbinical shiur, but nightfall is when Shabbos happens.
Quote

LoveToLaugh's Photo LoveToLaugh 23 Feb 2012

I don't know- I actually believe that it's the effort that counts when it comes to these kind of things. Like if you drip a little milk in your chicken soup does it matter if it's 1/100 or 2/100 of the contents?
I'm not convinced that getting the correct number is part of orthodoxy as you say.

I'd love to believe like you, that its the effort and not the minute details that count. Believe me, that sits a lot better with me and does seem to make more sense. But reality is its just not the case. There are so many clear and specific numeric things tied in to so many laws, you can't just say 'well do whatever you want as long as the effort is there'. There are 8 nights of chanukah, 3 different ways a sukkah can be made, specific amounts of knots in tzitzis, hours to wait after eating meat, and loads of opinions as to what exactly a k'zais means and how much matza you have to stuff your face with at a seder. Again, as I mentioned with the timing of when shabbos starts and stops, or for that matter yom tov. Orthodoxy definitely believes that there is a moment before sunset that its still a holiday or sabbath but all of a sudden, minutes later its not. In other areas such as women preparing for tevilah, one also needs to be very detail oriented and not just have 'the right effort and thoughts'.

So as much as I LIKE your opinion of what God wants and expects, it doesn't seem to jive with practical halacha. I once heard a shiur that there is a r

The 72 minutes is a bit of a misconception: the Halacha is that one may bentch as long as the food is not yet digested. The poskim write that as long as he is not yet hungry for that food, he can assume that it has not yet digested. Then the problem arises: that's all well and good if he ate to satiety the first time; if he originally ate less than enough to satisfy him, he is immediately still hungry for that food, yet it is certainly not yet digested. There is therefore a rule of thumb (I think it's a Mogen Avraham) that a kezayis of food - the minimum shiur for bentching - certainly does not digest in less time than it takes to walk 4 mil, or 72 minutes, so one can certainly bentch for at least that long. Therefore, it is correct that someone could technically eat a kezayis every hour or so and bentch once at the end of the day. However, if one is meisiach daas from eating in between, one would still need to make a new bracha rishona, as well as wash anew for bread. Additionally, it is not lechatchila to move on to other things before bentching, lest one forget to bentch.

As far as 72 and not 73, the Gemara asks a similar question, and says "all of the shiurim of chachamim are thus", IOW a shiur needs to be made, and the line has to be drawn somewhere, and if we ask what about a drop less or more the shiur can never stand anywhere. Shabbos, BTW, is a different question, since it's not a rabbinical shiur, but nightfall is when Shabbos happens.


Thank you snag. This repsonse was very informative. So you feel that its not a magical time thing as much as a hesech hadaas issue....can you expound a bit as to what hesech hadaas is? I know anything big like sleeping is definitely an issue, what about leaving the table to read, as many people do at the Friday nite seudah?
Quote

Snag's Photo Snag 23 Feb 2012

Thank you snag. This repsonse was very informative. So you feel that its not a magical time thing as much as a hesech hadaas issue....can you expound a bit as to what hesech hadaas is? I know anything big like sleeping is definitely an issue, what about leaving the table to read, as many people do at the Friday nite seudah?

It seems I put too many separate things in my post :)

Bracha acharona depends on digestion, with 72 minutes being a "loophole" of sorts.

Bracha rishona depends on hesech hadaas, which is not intending to continue eating, or doing something which completely removes one from the seudah, so to speak.
Quote

LoveToLaugh's Photo LoveToLaugh 23 Feb 2012

It seems I put too many separate things in my post :)

Bracha acharona depends on digestion, with 72 minutes being a "loophole" of sorts.

Bracha rishona depends on hesech hadaas, which is not intending to continue eating, or doing something which completely removes one from the seudah, so to speak.


Ok, thanks. Digestion -- wouldn't it seem to make sense that it should take 6 hours after meat is eaten to digest giving the eater that much longer to bentch?
Quote

Savannah's Photo Savannah 23 Feb 2012

I don't think G-d is going to reject your "thanks for the food" at the 73 minute mark. hth.

As far as 72 and not 73, the Gemara asks a similar question, and says "all of the shiurim of chachamim are thus", IOW a shiur needs to be made, and the line has to be drawn somewhere, and if we ask what about a drop less or more the shiur can never stand anywhere.

On a certain level, PD is right. In the times of the Gemara they didn't have clocks so a measurement of time was a lot more fluid, but Snag is also right that since we have clocks now and things have been quantified, the halacha is the halacha. How Hashem judges what you're doing is not up to us to try to figure out.
Quote

Snag's Photo Snag 23 Feb 2012

Ok, thanks. Digestion -- wouldn't it seem to make sense that it should take 6 hours after meat is eaten to digest giving the eater that much longer to bentch?

That's a good question. IIRC, the poskim specify that the 6 hours after meat is because of a "lingering taste" (טעם נמשך), not digestion per se. However, this lingering taste is engendered by digestion - unswallowed meat does not generate a taam nimshach. Also, even a tiny scrap of meat requires the waiting period, despite the fact that it certainly would be digested more quickly.
Quote

LoveToLaugh's Photo LoveToLaugh 23 Feb 2012

That's a good question. IIRC, the poskim specify that the 6 hours after meat is because of a "lingering taste" (טעם נמשך), not digestion per se. However, this lingering taste is engendered by digestion - unswallowed meat does not generate a taam nimshach. Also, even a tiny scrap of meat requires the waiting period, despite the fact that it certainly would be digested more quickly.

Which I guess explains why there are some sects of Judaism that holds 3 or even only 1 hour may be enough to wait.
Quote

Snag's Photo Snag 23 Feb 2012

Which I guess explains why there are some sects of Judaism that holds 3 or even only 1 hour may be enough to wait.

well, it goes like this:

the gemara records a middas chassidus (of mar ukva) who waited "from one seudah to another" between meat and milk. the vast majority of the poskim understand this to be a time-related thing, with the time between one seudah and the next being in the range of six hours (minor variations on the six hours exist, such as 5 1/2, etc.). rabbeinu tam understands it differently, as meaning that they can't be eaten at the same meal, but bentching and starting a new seudah is sufficient separation (with kinuach, hadacha, and netillas yadayim). the poskim cite a zohar which supports rabbeinu tam's position, with the added caveat that an hour's time is also needed in between. some poskim understand the hour to be a sort of compromise between rabbeinu tam and the other poskim. regardless, both six hours and one hour are firmly well-sourced among the poskim.

3 hours, the germanic minhag, has more murky origins. there is a rabbeinu yerucham which mentions a three-hour separation, but it might be a mistake, and there is no other support or explanation for this minhag.
Quote

LoveToLaugh's Photo LoveToLaugh 23 Feb 2012

Wow. I'm realizing how little I know about this area of halacha.....
Quote

Snag's Photo Snag 23 Feb 2012

Wow. I'm realizing how little I know about this area of halacha.....

every time i start a sugya, especially in halacha, i realize how little i knew about it before.
Quote

Red Hare's Photo Red Hare 25 Feb 2012

LTL, after the initial 72 minutes, are you still sitting at the table? did you eat and drink nothing?

You can alwlays wash, eat another kazayis, and then bentch.
Quote

Snag's Photo Snag 25 Feb 2012

LTL, after the initial 72 minutes, are you still sitting at the table? did you eat and drink nothing?

You can alwlays wash, eat another kazayis, and then bentch.

Kebeitzah. Otherwise you run into a safek bracha for washing.
Quote